Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Oklahoma cops arrest suspect who killed elderly couple then tie him to another homicide from hours earlier

Chambers led multiple law enforcement agencies on a frantic chase after allegedly committing a double murder in two separate counties

Madeline Sherratt
Thursday 19 December 2024 12:23 GMT
Richard Dewayne Chambers, 42, of Oklahoma City, was taken to the Pontotoc County jail in connection with the death of two senior citizens and one woman
Richard Dewayne Chambers, 42, of Oklahoma City, was taken to the Pontotoc County jail in connection with the death of two senior citizens and one woman (Hughes County Sheriff's Office)

Oklahoma cops have arrested a man that they believe murdered three elderly people during a crime spree Wednesday.

Richard Dewayne Chambers, 42, of Oklahoma City, was captured near Non, a community in southern Hughes County – approximately 100 miles southeast of Oklahoma City – at around 8:15 a.m. on December 19 following a frantic overnight manhunt, according to the Hughes County Sheriff’s Office.

The assailant is being held on suspicion of gunning down 84-year-old Robert Peliti and 70-year-old Jackie Peliti, of County Road 1512, Allen at 11:30 p.m. Tuesday.

But in a shocking revelation, only discovered upon finding the deceased elderly pair, police suspect Chambers unleashed a fatal attack on 62-year-old Annie Brown in Midwest City, hours before he killed the Pelitis in Pontotoc County.

The killings began when he reportedly shot and murdered Brown – whose backyard he had been living in – stole her car and drove towards the Pottawatomie and Pontotoc counties.

Chambers was arrested Tuesday night and taken to the Pontotoc County jail for the pending charges, said the Hughes County Sheriff’s Office
Chambers was arrested Tuesday night and taken to the Pontotoc County jail for the pending charges, said the Hughes County Sheriff’s Office (Hughes County Sheriff’s Office)

Upon arrival, he began knocking on doors and asking local residents for gas for Brown’s vehicle said Pontotoc County Undersheriff Arnold Scott to The Ada News.

He eventually stopped at a woman’s home in Ada at around 9 p.m to ask for fuel, said initial reports. But the woman – who wished to remain anonymous – claimed she didn’t have any and encouraged Chambers to ask her neighbors who were more likely to have some – the Pelitis.

However, little did she know that they would become his next victims, said Scott.

As her concerns mounted, the woman who lived by herself alerted her boyfriend – who also lives in Ada. He then reportedly traveled to the Pelitis home and encountered Chambers, said police.

The boyfriend reportedly attempted to blockade Chambers’ vehicle but he managed to escape and fled east along Oklahoma’s State Highway 1.

It was at this time when Pontotoc County sheriff’s deputies were called to the brutal scene where they discovered the Peliti couple gravely injured and bloodied with gunshot wounds, reported The Ada News.

Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation Public Information manager Hunter McKee told the outlet: “[Jackie Peliti] was pronounced dead at the scene. [Robert Peliti] was transported to a local hospital, where he later passed away.”

The 42-year old double homicide suspect was eventually found hiding in a barn near the community of Non, officials shared
The 42-year old double homicide suspect was eventually found hiding in a barn near the community of Non, officials shared (Hughes County Sheriff’s Office)

It remains unclear how but police were able to connect Chamber’s vehicle registration details with the owner Annie Brown – prompting calls to the Midwest City Police Department to request a welfare check.

This is when Midwest police officers reportedly discovered Brown’s dead body with “what appeared to be a gunshot wound”, said Midwest City police to Ada News.

As the night unfolded, Chambers was quickly discovered by Hughes County sheriff’s deputies parked on the shoulder of a highway but managed to flee again on foot into a wooded area, said Scott.

A manhunt ensued near Non and he was eventually found hiding in a barn.

Multiple law enforcement officers were involved in the multicounty operation.

Chambers was arrested and taken to Pontotoc County jail for the pending charges, said the Hughes County Sheriff’s Office.

Pontotoc County District Attorney Erik Johnson is reportedly planning to file murder charges for his alleged crimes, reports Ada News.

The Independent contacted Midwest City police and Pontotoc County Sheriff’s Office for information.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in