Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

As it happenedended

Elizabeth Holmes sentencing: Theranos founder to face restitution hearing after being jailed for 11 years

Prosecutors are demanding that Holmes be given 15 years in prison

Oliver O'Connell,Bevan Hurley
Sunday 20 November 2022 12:56 GMT
Jury finds Elizabeth Holmes guilty of fraud

Theranos founder Elizabeth Homes has been sentenced to more than 11 years in prison for defrauding investors of the blood-testing startup.

Holmes, who plans on appealing, will not have to report for her 135-month prison sentence until April 2023, the judge announced during the hearing.

“I am devastated by my failings,” a heavily-pregnant Holmes said in a tearful courtroom apology.

“I have felt deep pain for what people went through, because I failed them.”

Prosecutors had asked Judge Edward Davila to sentence Holmes to 15 years in prison and that she pay $800m in restitution for her role in the company’s fraudulent claims.

Holmes’ lawyers cast her as a scapegoat who overcame a toxic relationship with Theranos COO Ramesh “Sunny” Balwani to become a loving mother.

Holmes was convicted in January of three felony counts of wire fraud and one felony count of conspiracy to commit fraud.

Judge Davila said he would schedule a restitution hearing to determine how much Holmes must repay at a later date.

Elizabeth Holmes’ attorneys say investor loss came to $48m

Attorneys for both sides have been arguing for some time over how much Elizabeth Holmes defrauded investors out of.

Prosecutors put the figure at $804m, while Holmes’ lawyers say it is $48m.

Two hours into the hearing, Judge Davila has called a 15 minute break.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 19:59

The sentencing hearing is resuming

Judge Edward Davila has returned to the courtroom and we’re back underway.

Scott Budman is in the courtroom for NBC Bay Area.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:22

Judge Davila is addressing objections before moving on to sentencing guidelines

We’re approaching the business end of the sentencing now.

Judge Davila is going over the numerous objections that arose, and will then talk about his sentencing-guideline calculations.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:26

Judge Davila won’t consider potential harm to patients

A victory of sorts for Elizabeth Holmes — the judge won’t consider harm to Theranos patients in deciding on a sentence.

Ethan Baron, of Mercury News, has more.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:31

Judge rejects $800m investor loss figure submitted by prosecutors

Another ruling goes in favour of the Theranos founder.

Dorothy Atkins of Law 360 tweets: “The judge notes Theranos was a private company and the reality is that none of the investors are likely to recover a return on their investments. He adds that estimating the value of shares given the fraud ‘is challenging’.”

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:36

10 victims, $385m lost

Judge Davila says he will sentence Holmes based on her defrauding 10 victims of a total of $385m, according to Law 360.

Among the victims were Rupert Murdoch and the family of former Education Secretary Betsy DeVos.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:42

Holmes was not the leader of the criminal acts, Judge Davila says

Judge Davila’s comment appears to lay primary blame for the Theranos scandal with Ramesh Balwani, who will be sentenced next month.

He said Holmes was the leader of the company, but not of the criminal activity.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:44

Judge Davila says he won’t set restitution today

Judge Edward Davila will not impose a financial penalty on Holmes today, he has just said.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:50

Judge considering a sentence of between and 11 and 14 years

Judge Edward Davila says the sentencing guidelines indicate a sentence of between 11 and 14 years.

Important to note, this is not the actual sentence, but a sign of where he might be heading.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 20:56

Prosecutors say Holmes craved media attention

Holmes’ need for attention fuelled the fraud, prosecutors tell Judge Davila.

They have asked for a 15 year prison sentence as a deterrent in the high-profile case.

The defense is now making their final arguments.

Bevan Hurley18 November 2022 21:19

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in