Nuclear fusion – live: Scientists announce major ‘limitless clean energy’ breakthrough

‘This is game-changing, world-improving, lives-saving history unfolding in real-time,’ Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm says

Scientists achieve historic fusion ‘ignition’ to produce ‘near-limitless’ clean energy

The United States has announced a nuclear fusion breakthrough, a historic step towards the promise of “near-limitless” clean energy.

“It will go down in the history books,” said Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm on Tuesday in Washington DC alongside scientists from the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California.

For 70 years, hundreds of scientists and engineers have attempted to replicate the energy process of atoms fusing together that powers the sun and other stars.

It is an enormously complex - and expensive - process which is highly unstable due to the high temperatures and pressures involved.

Now, for the first time, the California lab team used lasers to achieve a “net energy gain”, producing more energy in a fusion reaction than was used to ignite it.

Scientists heralded the breakthrough but said there were still decades of work to be done before fusion would be powering our everyday lives.

Nevertheless, the fusion breakthrough has the potential to significantly impact the trajectory of the climate crisis - driven by the planet-heating emissions created by burning fossil fuels.

Key Points

• Scientists finally achieve ‘holy grail’ of nuclear fusion power
• Nuclear fusion breakthrough holds promise of ‘near-limitless’ clean energy
• ‘Massive challenges’ facing researchers working to implement new science
• US scientists achieve ‘holy grail’ net gain nuclear fusion reaction: report
• VIDEO: Scientists achieve historic fusion ‘ignition’ to produce ‘near-limitless’ clean energy

[13 December 2022 18:25 · Gustaf Kilander]

Energy Secretary says fusion could help put US on path to zero carbon emissions

US Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm said on Tuesday that the nuclear fusion achievement revealed on Tuesday “essentially unlocked a whole new source of clean energy”.

“More energy came out of these reactions than put into it,” she said, adding to CNN that “if we could get this scale, this will be an amazing endeavour of ... achieving the goal of zero-carbon emission power”.

“We have a goal of getting to net-zero energy by 2050, so that would be within that time frame. But now that this breakthrough has happened, the scientists can go to work on improving the process,” she added, referencing President Joe Biden’s stated goal of creating a commercial fusion reactor within 10 years.

“We have a lot more work to make sure it’s not just the United States, it’s other countries as well. So our example, both in the fusion example — as well as in all of these other technologies and policies — are being looked at very seriously by other countries who also want to do their part,” she said.

[13 December 2022 18:50 · Gustaf Kilander]

Experiment simulated ‘the conditions of a star'

Jill Hruby, the under-secretary for nuclear security, said that the US has taken “the first tentative steps towards a clean energy source that could revolutionize the world”.

The experiment included “192 high-energy lasers” being aimed at “a target about the size of a peppercorn, heating a capsule of deuterium and tritium to over three million degrees Celsius and briefly simulating the conditions of a star and achieving ignition”.

Arati Prabhakar, the Biden science advisor, said that researchers “shot a bunch of lasers at a pellet of fuel and more energy was released from that fusion ignition than the energy of the lasers”.

[13 December 2022 19:15 · Gustaf Kilander]

VIDEO: ‘This is one of the most impressive scientific feats of the 21st century,’ energy secretary says

[13 December 2022 19:40 · Gustaf Kilander]

Scientists achieve energy gain in lab experiments

Fusion has always been a strong alternative when concerned about the impact on the climate of emissions from other energy sources.

Fusion combines hydrogen atoms into helium within the sun and the stars, which leads to sunlight and warmth heating the planets.

The process has been proven to be a clean source of energy in lab experiments, unlike fossil fuels, and nuclear energy which leaves behind radioactive waste.

But until now, scientists have been unable to retain more energy from the reactions than they used.

At 1.03am on 5 December, scientists used 192 lasers to blast a cylinder holding a small amount of hydrogen, creating three megajoules of energy while only putting in 2.05 megajoules, The New York Times reported.

[13 December 2022 20:10 · Gustaf Kilander]

PHOTOS: Scientists reveal new discovery at Department of Energy press briefing

Scientists, engineers and administrators from the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratories pose for a group photograph at the Department of Energy (Getty Images)

Dr. Marvin Adams, Deputy Administrator for Defense Programs of the Department of Energy's National Nuclear Security Administration holds up a visual aid (REUTERS)

Scientists, engineers and administrators from the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratories prepare for a group photograph at the Department of Energy (Getty Images)

Director of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory Kim Budil speaks during the announcement of a major scientific breakthrough in fusion energy (EPA)

[13 December 2022 20:40 · Gustaf Kilander]

‘300 megajoules at the wall, two megajoules at the laser'

The Department of Energy declared the 5 December nuclear fusion energy as a success because when the hundreds of lasers struck the cylinder holding a small amount of hydrogen, 2.05 megajoules were shot at the target and 3.15 megajoules of energy came out.

But that didn’t factor in the energy that was required to create the lasers themselves – so-called wall-socket energy, The Washington Post noted.

The director of the Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, Kim Budil, said at the press conference on Tuesday that there were “300 megajoules at the wall, two megajoules at the laser”.

[13 December 2022 21:10 · Harry Cockburn]

‘Success, however long it takes, would be transformational'

The long-held promise of nuclear fusion is that it could provide energy in such abundance that it would effectively replace all other forms of power, bringing free, unlimited energy to people around the world, revolutionising our societies, and helping to bring the emissions driving the climate crisis to heel.

Scientists are now cautiously optimistic that we could be witnessing a major breakthrough with the potential to radically alter the energy landscape.

Professor Sir Robin Grimes, of Imperial College London, said on Monday: “This is a key step on a possible pathway to commercial fusion. It demonstrates and underpins our basic understanding of the physics, and is an engineering triumph.

“Nevertheless, extracting this energy in a way that it can be harnessed, and developing the materials that can stand up to continuous operation, are massive challenges. There is no doubt, the prize is worth the effort. Success, however long it takes, would be transformational.”

[13 December 2022 21:40 · Gustaf Kilander]

Laser used in experiment housed in football stadium complex

The laser needed to create the required reaction was so large that it was housed in a football stadium complex, The Washington Post noted.

It was built after the project ran over budget and faced years of delays.

Producing electricity from fusion would need the reaction, referred to as “ignition,” to take place every second of the day, the paper reported.

Reaching that point would require engineering on a massive scale. Merely creating a small amount of energy gain puts so much pressure on the expensive equipment that it at times breaks.

[13 December 2022 22:10 · Harry Cockburn]

The risk posed by unguarded optimism about unlimited free energy

The risk posed by unguarded optimism about the prospect of unlimited free energy is that it could undo the small steps that have already been taken to decarbonise the energy sector and other industries that have largely depended on fossil fuels.

Just as polluting industries are already factoring in scarcely adequate carbon capture technology in pursuit of their own net zero targets, fusion must not be treated as a climate crisis “get out of jail free” card.

The technology cannot be ready within the time window required to meet the climate targets governments are already failing to meet. Our society’s priority must remain the rapid curtailment of greenhouse gas emissions.

It may not be as sexy, but a combination of energy efficiency, insulation, heat pumps and a broader rollout of renewables remains our best shot for tackling the climate crisis and building greater energy security.

[13 December 2022 22:40 · Gustaf Kilander]

VIDEO: Laboratory shares footage outlining experiment process