With the Tories wrecking their brand, the betting markets say a hung parliament is odds-on

Dismissing the Grenfell Tower victims, doctoring interview footage and saying people on benefits should be put down – is there anything the Tories won't do to ruin themselves? They're becoming the Ratners of politics

James Moore
Thursday 07 November 2019 14:26 GMT
Comments
Andrew Bridgen defends Jacob Rees-Mogg over Grenfell comment

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

Boris Johnson’s Tory Party seems hellbent upon destroying its brand. Or at least, what passed for one.

The archetypal case study of the brand apocalypse is Ratners, the jeweller that once was a high street star (when such things still existed). Its star fell when chairman Gerald Ratner stood up at the Royal Albert Hall and said that when people asked how he could sell a sherry decanter at £4.95, he told them it was because it was “total crap”. That’s what the business became in the aftermath.

The Tories haven’t had just one “Ratners” moment. They’ve had a stocking full of them.

The race is now on for the Oscar for biggest tosser with a blue rosette. Jacob Rees-Mogg looked like a lock with his declaration that it would have been “common sense” for residents of the Grenfell tower block to ignore fire brigade advice to “stay put”.

But then Andrew Bridgen went and followed it up, suggesting that the Moggster was cleverer than the victims so would have gotten himself out. Politically speaking, it’s hard to imagine anything more stupid.

As a plan to use the impartial civil service to attack Labour spending plans was blocked, others were leaping into the fray. Welsh secretary Alun Cairns resigned amid questions over what he knew about an aide’s torpedoing of a rape trial. After some juvenile rube doctored a Good Morning Britain interview with Labour’s Sir Keir Starmer, Tory party chairman James Cleverly made a tit of himself trying to defend it.

To cap it all, a Welsh Tory candidate turned out to have said people appearing on Benefits Street should be “put down” – and her local party stood by her.

As an early Christmas present to opposition strategists, these episodes are like giving a teenager one of each of the newest X-Box, PS4, and Nintendo Switch consoles along with lifetime access to every game ever published. They must have been pinching themselves, perhaps asking who it was that slipped acid into their morning coffee.

But here’s the scary question: How much damage has this really done?

The Tory brand wasn’t exactly starry before these gaffes. It’s fair to ask whether it was already so totally crap that all this has simply served to confirm what we already knew.

Ratner’s arguably stood for affordable quality in its heyday, and its customers bought into that until Gerald’s ham-fisted attempt at a joke turned the gesture of putting anything from one of his shops under the Christmas tree into a potential insult.

Tory voters? Some might kid themselves that the party actually stands for opportunity and free enterprise and freedom and one nation and all the other stuff they like to talk about before the cameras. That they’re not just trying to kid us that nobody in the party calls for the burning of benefit claimants, muslims, hippies and witches when they think there are no pesky reporters around.

They’re probably in the minority though.

There’s a reason people tell pollsters porkies rather than admit that they’re planning to vote Tory. They see the red-faced racist declaring himself a “proud Tory” at the golf club bar and they decide they’d really rather not be associated with him in polite company.

“Oh, no, that’s not me at all. I’m planning to vote Lib Dem didn’t you know!”

It's easy to see through this. Amazon pays minimal tax, sparks scandal over its treatment of workers, has contributed to carnage on the high street. It has nonetheless become what they refer to in the trade as a “super brand” because its choice, pricing and customer service are compelling. Its customers are able to look at the smile logo and close their eyes to the darker side of the business.

It’s very different with the Tories. It’s self-evident that that blue tree of theirs is made of rotten wood.

Professionalism? Nope. Just look at Boris Johnson’s tenure at the foreign office. Economic competence? Brexit put paid to that one. Since 2017 Britain has boasted one of the world’s slowest growing economies. Moderation? Um, really?

Thing is, though, those comments of Jacob Rees-Mogg’s, they were so thoroughly awful, so ugly, so contemptible, so out-and-out, well, nasty, they do sort of plumb new depths. Add in the other stuff and they might just force a few people to question their consciences when they’re alone in the polling booth. They remove any wiggle room from the equation.

But, but, but Jeremy Corbyn is awful! Sorry, that won’t wash. Some 80 per cent of Labour MPs agree with that, and his efforts to purge them have proved less than successful. He won’t get it all his own way even if he somehow finds a way to win a majority (which he won’t), and you don’t have to vote Labour anyway.

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

Johnson has, meanwhile, told the Tories that they either sign up to this brand or get lost. There’s no longer any hiding place for them or for their voters.

Mogg has made it clear through breathing halitosis over the campaign that if you are planning to vote Tory it says something about you. And not something good.

The polls moving against the party? It could be down to shy Tories again. But the betting markets have also shifted. A hung parliament is now odds-on. Perhaps people realise that.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in