Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Lewis Moody: If it ain't broke, don't fix it - Lancaster must get the job

Moody Views

Lewis Moody
Thursday 01 March 2012 01:00 GMT
Comments
Stuart Lancaster has nothing to worry about - these England players look like they will follow him to the ends of the earth
Stuart Lancaster has nothing to worry about - these England players look like they will follow him to the ends of the earth (Getty Images)

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

If last Saturday showed anything it is that Stuart Lancaster and his coaching team are on the right lines. So why are some people still calling for a big name to take over England? To me it would be change for change's sake and would seem so pointless.

Of course, I can see the attraction in someone like Nick Mallett. He's a great coach and has the CV. But now Stuart has brought this team this far he should be allowed to continue. Otherwise all the good work will be forsaken and England will have to start from scratch again.

I like the feel of this England set-up. The sceptics may look at Stuart's credentials and say: "Oh, he was head coach at Leeds and they were relegated and then he only took charge of the England Academy and the Saxons, so what has he achieved?" Even if they ignore the fact that Leeds had the smallest resources in the league, they clearly can't have been watching the Wales game.

Here was an inexperienced England side who were expected to lose comfortably to Wales and yet they left the pitch at the end of 80 proper Test minutes of rugby feeling they should have won. The improvements in both attack and defence were obvious and showed the strides Stuart and his team have made.

There's some serious coaching talent backing up Stuart, talent that would also probably be lost when a new man comes in with his own team. From what I've heard, Graham Rowntree and Andy Farrell are phenomenal on the training ground, and they are only going to grow into their roles. The reports back are all positive.

There is a great atmosphere within the camp and there's a genuine chance to forge something special. I know there's a big difference between club and international rugby, but the example I'd like to use is Exeter, who are the surprise package of this season's Premiership.

They're a squad who aren't full of any stars, don't have any real draw players, but week in, week out, they overperform and win games they shouldn't on paper. That's just because of the culture and belief they've created down there; they know what they want to do and, more to the point, they know they want to do it for each other. Having that tight-knit squad mentality is so important. Stuart, Graham and Andy are creating that with England, and add in the star quality they have at their disposal and it will go a long way. Why change it?

There have been a lot of debuts handed out in the first three games. Some of the players won't be seen at this level again, some will. But Stuart and his staff now have a better idea who is up to the task and, in a transitional period, that is an exercise which must be done. Another reason to keep faith in him.

Yet my worry is that, if England finish with only two wins, the clamour for a top name will grow. I said at the start of the Six Nations, that three wins would have to be seen as a success. I am still optimistic England will win one of their remaining two matches, but I honestly believe, that coming off the back of those opening two triumphs on the road and with the extra charge the first game at Twickenham brings, the best shout was against Wales. Saying that, there are still chances. Stade de France is a cauldron, but the boys have shown they can cope in a hostile environment – I assure you they don't get more hostile than Murrayfield. Furthermore, France will have only had a week's turnaround, compared with England's fortnight, after the rearranged fixture with Ireland and this could be a factor. But still, a win over there will be a lot to expect from a young side.

Ireland must be the primary hope. Like France, they will have played three games on the bounce when it comes to the final weekend and may show up at Twickenham fatigued. They're an ageing team – albeit one with so much experience and quality – and may have nothing to chase but pride. England, in contrast, may well be playing for the jobs of their coaching staff and that could be so galvanising.

I sincerely wish they pull it off for them and, if they don't, I hope Stuart and his team are handed the contracts anyway. They're in the process of fixing, so don't break it up again.

Lewis Moody is a TAG Heuer ambassador. TAG Heuer are the official watch of England Rugby

Farrell Jnr can avoid pitfalls with awesome Andy on side

My plea on behalf of Owen Farrell is leave him be. Please don't burden him with unrealistic expectations or big comparisons. Just remember he is only 20 years of age and still has so much learning and improving ahead of him.

Yes, it is very exciting when a new player emerges and I was as impressed as anyone by his display in the No 10 jersey last Saturday. He showed some real flair, and dare I say it, his chip through reminded me of Johnny Wilkinson circa 2002. But some of the reaction was over-the-top and won't do him any favours.

Wouldn't it be great if we could just let him get on with it and look back in a couple of years and say "what a player we have here"? He is so young for such a pressurised position and will inevitably make mistakes, as every young player does. Heaping pressure on those inexperienced shoulders and applying the superstar tag will only add to the load he must carry. Be patient, I urge.

The comforting thought is the father he has backing him up. Andy was a great player and is an awesome guy. He was one of the finest in terms of attitude and application I ever saw on the training ground. He has a simple mindset and is straight-talking; qualities which Owen seems to have inherited.

Andy certainly knows the pitfalls of being young and gifted. He won a Challenge Cup at 17, played for Great Britain at 18 and then captained the Lions on tour to New Zealand at 21. Now that's pressure. Perhaps he may remind Owen as much.

If anyone can, Warburton's the man

As a No 7, I appreciated Sam Warburton's performance at Twickenham more than most. I would say that, at 23, he has everything it takes to become a world-class open-side – but, plainly, he already is. Goodness knows how good he will become as he develops.

His work on the ground was imperious and it was interesting Wales went to him in the line-out so often. But it was his try-saving tackle on Manu Tuilagi which will live longest in my memory.

Essentially, it was an arm tackle and, having played with Manu for club and country, I can confirm that he breaks through arm tackles on any given day. Not this time, however, and he will be disappointed. Manu can take comfort in the fact that Warburton did everything right at this critical moment.

Will he take the Grand Slam in Cardiff on 17 March? Wales will do it if they can handle the pressure. The tag of favouritism probably got to them a little at Twickenham, but they came through. It will be fascinating to see how they handle all the hype in the next few weeks. My guess is that Captain Warburton will prove such an asset.

Lewis Moody is a TAG Heuer ambassador. TAG Heuer are the official watch of England Rugby

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in