England vs Ireland player ratings: Who was the star man at Twickenham in World Cup warm-up?

England 21 Ireland 13

Julian Bennett
Saturday 05 September 2015 19:25 BST
Comments
(Getty Images)

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

ENGLAND

Mike Brown 7/10

Yet to recapture his fine form from last year’s Six Nations but was exceptionally solid defensively.

Anthony Watson 9/10

A once-in-a-generation player who is Jason Robinson’s true heir. Another exceptional try here.

Jonathan Joseph 8/10

Danced through defences, doing so three times in the opening minutes before fading slightly.

Brad Barritt 7/10

Solid defensively without offering as much as his team-mates going forward – but it was ever thus.

Jonny May 9/10

An exceptional, electrifying performance capped with a superb try. Nailed down his place

George Ford 8/10

After the horrors of Paris a welcome return to form as Ford produced a composed, dynamic display.

Ben Youngs 9/10

Exceptional here, sniping around the fringes and a constant menace. A shoe-in for the Fiji game.

Joe Marler 7/10

Strong and abrasive in the loose, but the Harlequins man faded slightly after a bright start.

Tom Youngs 8/10

Superb in the loose but loose in the set-piece – and with the line-out working well his talents shone through.

Dan Cole 6/10

An improvement on Paris but still below-par. England need him to improve quickly.

Geoff Parling 7/10

Shored up the line-out as expected and stole a couple of the Irish into the bargain.

Courtney Lawes 6/10

England’s enforcer was surprisingly quiet, but may be saving himself for the challenges ahead.

Tom Wood 8/10

With James Haskell breathing down his neck Wood needed a performance – and he got one. Superb.

Chris Robshaw 7/10

Praised by the coaches afterwards this was a classic Robshaw performance – an utter nuisance for Ireland.

Ben Morgan 8/10

After 40 minutes’ rugby since January this was just what he needed. Back to his best just in time for World Cup.

IRELAND

Simon Zebo 5/10

Only his fourth start at full-back and inexperience showed as he was out-jumped by Watson for his try.

Tommy Bowe 3/10

Wing’s attempted tackle on May was embarrassing and set the tone for awful Irish first-half. Must do better.

Jared Payne 5/10

Most mortals would struggle in comparison with Brian O’Driscoll and Payne is no different.

Robbie Henshaw 5/10

Poor afternoon summed up by the forward-pass he threw when Ireland had a three-on-two on the break.

Dave Kearney 8/10

The only one of Ireland’s backs to emerge with credit, a challenge on Ford changing the game’s momentum.

Jonny Sexton 5/10

A strangely subdued game, with Ford thoroughly outplaying him. Must improve, and soon.

Conor Murray 6/10

Flinging his forehead into Joe Marler’s hip was never going to be a good idea. Forced off after 18 minutes.

Jamie Heaslip 6/10

Ireland’s game is based on the Heaslip, Murray, Sexton combination and when they fail to fire Ireland struggle.

Jack McGrath 7/10

A perfectly acceptable player but has one key problem – he isn’t Cian Healy. Did well but far from dynamic.

Rory Best 6/10

Within the first quarter wore the look of a man who was sick of being driven backwards.

Mike Ross 5/10

England came at the 35-year-old Leinster prop like a pack of rabid dogs at Twickenham.

Devin Toner 5/10

Ireland’s giant lock was made to appear Lilliputian by England’s early forward effort.

Paul O’Connell 8/10

Ireland’s inspirational skipper dragged his side back into the game with a fine, burrowing try.

Peter O’Mahoney 7/10

Ireland’s top tackler but was outplayed by Tom Wood, failing to bring the physical edge needed.

Sean O’Brien 6/10

Another who suffered in comparison with his opposite number, in this case Chris Robshaw.

How the bench fared

Ireland had a chance to snatch the game but their bench was thoroughly outplayed and out-thought.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in