Trent Alexander-Arnold, Harry Maguire and England’s key questions ahead of World Cup
If many of Southgate’s squad have never tasted failure, it is in part due to his choices. If they showed a loyalty to him, it is reciprocated
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.England have played their final game before November’s World Cup and before Gareth Southgate names his squad in October.
He can choose 26 players and will, though he said: “I don’t think it’s an ideal number.”
And, as his choices for the 1-0 defeat to Italy and the 3-3 draw with Germany show, many of them will be automatic picks for him, providing they are fit.
It leaves other questions for him to answer when turning a list of perhaps 35 candidates into his final 26.
What is the goalkeeping pecking order?
Monday may have been a fine night for Aaron Ramsdale. Nick Pope had a two-game audition to be Jordan Pickford’s deputy but his unconvincing kicking presented a problem even before a late error gifted Kai Havertz Germany’s equaliser. Ramsdale might now be second in line when Pickford returns, while the presumption is that Dean Henderson will be the odd man out.
Does he omit Trent Alexander-Arnold?
Southgate has ducked decisions by selecting all four right-backs in various squads. But if there is a separate debate about whether Liverpool’s creator-in-chief should be first choice for his country, it has become ever more apparent he is fourth in his manager’s thinking. And while Kyle Walker really ranks as one of the centre-backs in a 3-4-3 formation, Reece James and Kieran Trippier are both ahead of Alexander-Arnold. Southgate may rationalise that he gives one of the extra spots in his squad to someone who stands a greater chance of playing. He seems increasingly unafraid of criticism for sidelining Alexander-Arnold.
Does he take Ben Chilwell?
Because if so, then Trippier is less likely to play on the left and, in turn, there is less need for Alexander-Arnold. The probability is that Southgate was disappointed Chelsea signed Marc Cucurella, limiting Chilwell’s chances to play at club level. But the combination of Bukayo Saka’s awkward night at left wing-back in Milan and Luke Shaw’s fine display against Germany, which might propel him into the starting 11 and then necessitate having a like-for-like replacement, suggests Chilwell goes to Qatar.
Who are his back-up centre-backs?
Everything indicates four names are inked in – John Stones (assuming his hamstring injury is not too serious), Harry Maguire (whatever his critics think), a renascent Eric Dier (who has started both games since his recall) and Walker.
That probably leaves two spots. None of Conor Coady, Marc Guehi and Fikayo Tomori were granted a minute’s action during the two September games. Coady – England’s player of Euro 2020, without playing, according to Steve Holland – has a reputation as a good tourist, but Dier’s ability to play in the middle and on the right of the three could make him redundant. England have fewest compelling choices on the left, Maguire’s role, where Guehi and Tomori could be competing for one position in the squad.
Tyrone Mings, as a left-footer, could come back into contention; James Tarkowski, excelling on the left for Everton, may be too far down the pecking order. That Ben White would prefer to play in the middle or on the right might count against him, though he is in Southgate’s thinking.
Should he pick a semi-fit Kalvin Phillips?
Southgate shows loyalty to those who have performed for him in the past and a 26-man squad gives him greater opportunity to. He was rewarded for selecting Maguire when he was not fit for the start of Euro 2020 though Jordan Henderson, who was not either, never recaptured his best form that summer.
Phillips was a beneficiary then, in a tournament when he was outstanding. But he may represent the greatest gamble now: with only 13 minutes’ football all season, having undergone shoulder surgery and lacking pre-World Cup friendlies to coax him back into shape.
James Ward-Prowse missed the final cut for Euro 2020; now his chances of dodging similar disappointment could depend on whether Southgate takes five central midfielders. It makes more sense to pursue a policy of safety in numbers if one of the first four is an injury doubt.
Is Jude Bellingham a starter?
Bellingham was England’s player of September. Injuries to Phillips and Henderson may have created an opening, but he took it. And while the sense is Southgate prefers to have two central midfielders behind the ball, the Borussia Dortmund teenager adds another dimension. He is surely starting in November. There is an outside chance that could help Conor Gallagher, if Southgate then wants another attack-minded central midfielder to cover for Bellingham.
Is Mason Mount a starter?
Mount’s equaliser against Germany was his first international goal in 18 months. A starter in the Euro 2020 final and Chelsea’s player of the year in successive seasons, he has nonetheless been leapfrogged by some of England’s other options on the flanks. Preferring 3-4-3 to 4-2-3-1 or 4-3-3 takes out one of his possible positions, even if it is a formation Chelsea often play. For now, Mount may be seen as an impact substitute.
Is it too late for Marcus Rashford and Jadon Sancho?
The answer could be different for each of the pair. Southgate said on Monday: “We would be foolish not to keep an open mind, especially with players who know us and can slot in comfortably.” If that applies to both of the Manchester United duo, Rashford may have two advantages: he has more experience and credit in the bank for Southgate’s England and he can double up as both winger and the third striking option. All of which could make Jarrod Bowen fallible after his poor start to the season.
As it is, Southgate will probably take six players who can operate as wingers, though some are versatile and each can figure more if he plays a back four. But Sancho may be seventh or eighth in line for one of those spots.
Who is Harry Kane’s deputy?
Neither Tammy Abraham nor Ivan Toney got a minute against Italy or Germany, which felt still more worrying for the uncapped Brentford man. The reality is that, over several years, no one has secured the role as the captain’s understudy, and Southgate said: “There are some really tight calls.” Club form could yet be decisive. That may give hope to Ollie Watkins or even Dominic Calvert-Lewin but, for now, Abraham looks the slight favourite.
Gareth Southgate’s possible squad
Goalkeepers: Pickford, Ramsdale, Pope
Defenders: Walker, Stones, Maguire, Dier, Coady, Guehi
Wing-backs: James, Trippier, Shaw, Chilwell
Midfielders: Rice, Henderson, Bellingham, Phillips, Ward-Prowse
Attacking midfielders: Sterling, Foden, Grealish, Mount, Saka, Rashford
Strikers: Kane, Abraham
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments