Video of endangered white rhino forced to perform in circus prompts outpouring of anger
Wild animal poses risk to public and trainer who rides on his back, warns expert
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Footage of an endangered white rhino trained to perform in a circus has prompted an outpouring of anger and calls to boycott shows featuring live animals.
Social-media users were furious at the videos taken in Russia showing a rhino being forced to parade or carry a man on its back in a circus ring, while the trainer holds whips at the ready.
Rhinos are rarely seen in circuses, although elephants have long been used – and are being phased out following years of protests about cruel training and the unnatural conditions they are kept in.
In a clip circulating online taken at the Russian State Circus, the rhino is made to sit and let the trainer clamber onto his back before setting off to tour the ring.
A couple of times the animal also appears to turn away quickly from the trainer as he approaches with a whip.
In another clip, suspected of having been shot at the Safari Circus in Moscow, what is thought to be the same rhino is seen on a circular platform under a bright spotlight, hesitating several times before stepping off.
Experts in wild-animal welfare said using a white rhino - which can weigh up to 2,300kg - in public show was extremely risky for the trainer and spectators.
“It could quickly cause injury to the trainer, and if there isn’t a substantial barrier, to the public,” said Chris Draper, of the Born Free wildlife charity. “However well trained it is, rhinos are naturally nervous and impulsive.”
The animal, probably hired out from one circus to another, would have been trained using cruel, painful methods behind the scenes to perform as instructed, he said.
“To see the animal in this circumstance when you’ve seen one in the wild is utterly incongruent,” he said. “Not only is it being exposed to substantial noise, but the use of the whip is wrong. They would say it doesn’t hurt, but if that’s the case why use it at all?”
Transporting the rhino around would also inflict stress and strain on him, Dr Draper added.
In a separate video, the rhino, Mafa, is filmed away from the ring, being fed by the trainer, Sergey Nesterov, who says: “I put a bed next to it, and I left it only when I had to eat, in order to spend more time with it. This way it got used to people.”
Mr Nesterov says it took a year to arrange the paperwork to transport Mafa from South Africa.
The Safari Circus’s website states that it uses exotic animals, and said that in 1996 Sergei Nesterov and Elena Fedotova decided to create a new attraction with exotic animals based on an older one created by Elena's parents.
Safari’s site features photos of the rhino, as well as shots of a kangaroo with a chain around its neck and boxing gloves on, apparently sparring with a human.
There are also photos of five white tigers in the ring with the trainer.
Facebook and Twitter users condemned the use of the rhino, saying the animal belonged in the wild and had not been domesticated like a cat or dog.
One said: “How can people be so cruel?”
Another, SY Woon, wrote: “Disgusting!! The methods used to train these wild animals to perform these demeaning tricks for entertainment involve significant abuse! Please do not ever support circuses that exploit animals for ‘entertainment’.”
Zoe Bond wrote: “Stolen from his mother and sold to a circus to be enslaved for life. He would have been beaten in his training to perform those unnatural 'tricks'.”
On Twitter, Shari Slater appealed to Russia’s Vladimir Putin, saying: “Can you please stop this! You have the power to make Russia a leader against animal cruelty.”
But JoAnna Lamb said the rhino appeared to be well cared for and the show was educational. Keeping it in a circus protected him from being killed by poachers, she said.
Classed as “near-threatened”, about 20,000 southern white rhinos are left in the world, most in South Africa, Namibia, Zimbabwe, and Kenya.
The Independent has asked the Russian embassy in London to comment but had not had a response at the time of publication.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments