Everything we know about the killing of Orsolya Gaal after her body was found in duffle bag
David Bonola has admitted killing his former lover and will spend up to 25 years in prison
The latest headlines from our reporters across the US sent straight to your inbox each weekday
Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US
Orsolya Gaal’s body was discovered stuffed in a hockey bag on in Forest Park in the borough of Queens, New York City, on 16 April.
The married mother-of-two, 51, had been stabbed nearly 60 times in her home and her body was dragged half a mile away and dumped near to a popular walking path on Metropolitan Avenue in the early hours of Saturday morning.
Police followed a trail of blood from the bag that led them about half a mile to an upscale gated community in Forest Hills.
Police arrested 44-year-old handyman David Bonola days later and charged him with murder.
Detectives said he had been in a relationship with Ms Gaal for about two years, and they had broken it off some time before she was killed.
On 2 November, Bonola pleaded guilty to her first-degree manslaughter.
How did Orsolya Gaal die?
Ms Gaal reportedly told son Leo she was going out to see a show on Friday night.
She is believed to have met up with a man before returning to the $2m family home later that evening.
A neighbour spotted Ms Gaal in her yard in the hours before her death.
Police say she was killed in the basement of the home. Sources familiar with the autopsy information say Ms Gaal suffered nearly 60 wounds with knife wounds to her to her neck, torso, left arm, fingers and hand.
Slashes to her palm and fingers appeared to be defensive wounds.
Surveillance footage shows a suspect believed to be the killer dragging a wheeled duffel sports bag containing her body around 4.30am on Saturday morning.
The bag was discovered by a dog walker just after 8am on a popular walking track on Metropolitan Avenue in Forest Hills, along a stretch of road that cuts through a park.
She did not have any ID on her. Police followed the bloody trail back to the family home on Juno St, half a mile away.
They found Leo alone on the top floor of the residence. Neighbours reported that he was led away in handcuffs by police for questioning, before being released later and cleared of any involvement in the crime.
The New York Daily News reported that Leo told investigators he didn’t know where his mother was.
Detectives found no signs of a break-in at the home, and believe the killer was known to Ms Gaal.
Officers have reportedly questioned another teenager who lives in the same Forest Hill neighbourhood.
Neighbour John Blankson told the Post he saw Ms Gaal walking around their shared backyard with her dog on Friday.
Chilling text messages
Unnamed police sources toldPIX11 that the killer used Ms Gaal’s cellphone to send a series of chilling text messages to her husband in the hours after she died.
The killer reportedly texted Howard Klein to say: “Your wife sent me to jail some years ago... I’m back.”
He also made an ominous warning: “Your whole family is next.”
Mr Klein, who was travelling back to New York from Portland, told the New York Post he feared his family were still in danger.
“There are concerns about our safety,” he told the Post. “Our lives are at risk.”
Mr Klein referred to the out-of-state trip in a since-deleted tweet. He also mentioned hedge-funder Bill Browder’s new book about Vladimir Putin.
“Just landed Portland OR before evaluating Ann Arbor again with my 17-year-old son,” Mr Klein posted.
“Highly recommend ‘Freezing Order’ @Billbrowder a man I’ve followed closely and admired since I started on Wall Street in 1997 broking EMEA & Russian equities to hedge funds like Hermitage.”
No suspects have been named in the case, and it’s unclear what the killer was referring to, and police have described the case as a “mystery”.
Who is Orsolya Gaal?
Ms Gaal is orginally from Hungary, and studied at the Budapest Business School College of International Management and Business.
Friends paid tribute to Ms Gaal, a stay-at-home mother, in Hungarian and English on her Facebook page.
“I’ll always remember how passionate you were about your boys and their education,” one friend wrote. “I’m so sorry about how you left this world but i hope you find peace in the afterlife.”
Another said: “A few years ago, you prayed for my little girl for me, and now I’m here praying for your family to be able to get thru this tragedy.”
Ms Gaal’s Facebook page shows she was a keen hiker, skier and traveller, and enjoyed attending live music performances.
According to a social media account, Ms Gaal had recently helped her youngest son Leo fundraise for his bar mitzvah.
Neighbours told the Post the bar mitzvah was cancelled after Mr Klein contracted Covid.
In a statement provided to The Independent, the NYPD said police received a 911 call at 8.11am on Saturday after a suspicious bag with blood on it was spotted at the corner of Metropolitan Avenue and Jackie Robinson Parkway.
Officers found Ms Gaal “unconscious and unresponsive” inside the duffle bag, and she was pronounced dead at the scene.
They followed a blood trail was several blocks to her home on Juno St.
“There are no arrests and the investigation remains ongoing at this time.”
Police sources told the Post that officers responded to a 911 call at the family home in May 2020 after Mr Klein reported his wife was missing. He later told police that she had been found.
The family had lived in the Tudor-style home for about nine years, according to a neighbour.
Husband Howard Klein founded boutique financial advisory firm RK Equities in 2002, and spent five years working as an investment banker in Hungary.
He has a Bachelor of Arts in economics from the University of Michigan and an MBA in finance from Columbia University.
Mr Klein is an expert on in natural resources including, gold, iron ore and lithium, and speaks regularly at investment conferences, according to an online profile.
A gruesome discovery
Glenn Van Nostrand was out walking his two Rhodesian ridgebacks on Saturday morning when he stumbled across Ms Gaal’s body in the duffle bag.
Initially he thought the Bauer-branded bag might have been thrown away.
His suspicions were raised when the dogs became agitated as they neared the bag, and he opened it and looked inside.
Mr Van Nostrand told The Post he thought it might have been a mannequin.
“It didn’t look very fleshy. It was more like a crash test dummy. I thought it was maybe some equipment being used for something. I didn’t think anything of it,” he told The Post.
He then noticed Ms Gaal’s black jeans and waist, and realised he was looking at a body, and called 911. He said Ms Gaal appeared to be lying in the foetal position.
After police showed up, he had intended to drop his dogs at home before going into the precinct to make a full report.
However, his two dogs picked up a scent of blood patches about 100m away from the body.
“Some of the cops followed me and the dogs to it,” he said.
‘Person of interest’ identified
According to unnamed police sources, the NYPD has identified a “person of interest” in connection with Ms Gaal’s murder.
The man is said to be known to her, and have access to the family home. There were no signs of forced entry at the Juno St address, and the ferocity of the attack on Ms Gaal suggests it was someone bearing a grudge.
On Monday afternoon, police removed an iMac computer and several other items from the family home in boxes and black plastic bags.
The family have not been seen at the home since Saturday afternoon.
‘Multiple suspects’ identified
The NYPD are investigating at “multiple suspects” as they continue to hunt for Ms Gaal’s killer.
They believe the attack was not premeditated, given how messy the crime scene was.
The New York Port reported detectives wanted to speak to a handyman who had previously done work at the property.
A law enforcement source told The Post: “[Detectives] don’t think it was a planned murder.
“He left a blood trail for five blocks from the house. It was like a trail of bread crumbs,” the source added.
“If you want to kill somebody, you try to make it a little cleaner, be a little more prepared. He didn’t go with something to move her body. He took something from the house.”
Reward offered by police
On Tuesday afternoon, police put up posters in the streets around Ms Gaal’s home offering a $3500 reward for information about the homicide.
The poster states: “Up to $3,500 reward for information regarding a homicide”, alongside a photo of the Klein-Gaal home.
“On Saturday, April 16th, 2022, at approximately 12:40am… An unknown perpetrator stabbed a 51-year-old Orsolya Gaal multiple times causing her death. The victim was found inside a duffel bag along Metropolitan Avenue in Queens,” police state.
Arrest made
On the night of Wednesday, 20 April, detectives went searching for David Bonola, 44. Bonola is a handyman and reportedly one of Ms Gaal’s former lovers. He was one of three men Ms Gaal contacted on the day of her murder.
Bonola found the detectives before they could find him. He reportedly approached the detectives and said “I heard you are looking for me.”
He was taken to the 112th precinct where he spoke with police and, allegedly, confessed to killing Ms Gaal.
Bonola reportedly explained that he had done work at Ms Gaal’s house and knew where she kept her spare key, which allowed him the access he needed to carry out the murder.
Guilty plea
On 2 November, Bonola admitted a charge of first-degree manslaughter and faces up to 25 years in prison.
Prosecutors said the pair had an argument and Bonola slashed Gaal’s throat before stabbing her a total of 58 times, the district attorney said.
Bonola had previously carried out repairs at the home, and had been in an on-again, off-again two year romantic relationship with Gaal.
He reportedly told police that he believed Gaal gave him HIV over the course of their affair, according to court records.
“She was cheating on me with somebody and she gave me HIV,” he told detectives when he was brought in for questioning.
On Wednesday, Bonola appeared before Queens Supreme Court Justice Michael Aloise where he pled guilty to her manslaughter.
Bonola was originally from Mexico and had been living in the US illegally, police said.
Through a translator, he told the judge that he understood the nature of the crime he was admitting.
Melinda Katz, the Queens District Attorney, said in a statement: “This heinous killing devastated an entire family, left two boys without a mother, and horrified the surrounding community.
“I want to thank my prosecutors for their exhaustive efforts in securing this plea.
“We express our sincerest condolences to the victim’s family and hope that today’s plea will allow them to begin to heal.”
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.