Call to act on ‘dangerous’ conditions around Westminster for disabled people
One peer said he had missed hospital appointments because he could not navigate along the streets around Parliament.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Disabled peers have spoken about being “harangued” on their way to Parliament as a report said not enough was being done to safeguard access to Westminster for the less abled.
A report by the Policy Exchange said protests had often blocked the passageway of disabled people as it called on the Metropolitan Police to do more to protect pedestrian walkways for those in wheelchairs and with other disabilities.
Lord Blencathra, in a testimony shared with the report writers, said he had missed hospital appointments due to his access being blocked.
The Conservative peer, who has multiple sclerosis and uses a wheelchair, said the rights of protesters should “not impede on the rights of others going about their daily lives”.
The way that the parliamentary authorities and the police are choosing to approach protests in Westminster has an impact on everyone, but the impact on those who are disabled is particularly egregious
“In recent years we have seen parliamentarians harangued, accosted, surrounded and intimidated in the area around Parliament,” Lord Blencathra told the report, titled A Culture Of Impunity: The Ongoing Erosion Of Disabled People’s Access To Parliament And Westminster.
He added: “As a result of the actions of protesters and the police’s failure to ensure a safe route of passage for people going about their lawful business, I am one of many who have been prevented from attending hospital appointments.
“The way that the parliamentary authorities and the police are choosing to approach protests in Westminster has an impact on everyone, but the impact on those who are disabled is particularly egregious.
“It would not be considered acceptable in any other location.”
Peers told the report that metal barricades put up during protests were difficult to navigate for disabled people and they often had to wait for a police officer to open a cordon for them to pass.
The report, published on Thursday, said that during April’s so-called The Big One protest organised by climate groups, stalls and gazebos blocked the pedestrian pavements on Parliament Square and Abingdon Street.
“Extinction Rebellion on their website claimed the occasion would be ‘accessible and welcoming’, but for many disabled people who sought to safely use the pavements in the immediate area this was far from the case,” the report said.
The culture of impunity which exists in the area around Parliament, Whitehall and Westminster has led to an intolerable and dangerous situation for disabled people which cannot be permitted to continue
“Parliamentarians and others using wheelchairs were forced to ask nearby police officers to clear a route through the crowds, so that they could pass through the demonstration safely in order to access the parliamentary estate.”
Extinction Rebellion defended the handling of the protest, with a spokesman insisting that “access to the Parliamentary Estate was assured at all times”.
The 27-page report recommends that the Metropolitan Police, in considering whether “serious disruption” is taking place during demonstrations, take into account “the burdens, including denial of access to pavements because of obstructions, which protest may place on disabled people (and other vulnerable groups)”.
The study also recommended action on tackling the discarding of public hire e-bikes and e-scooters on pavements in Westminster.
It said Westminster City Council had been “notably passive” on the issue.
The council has pushed back against the criticism, saying it had taken “decisive action to tackle” the problem of bikes and scooters being abandoned on walkways.
David Spencer, author of the Policy Exchange report and a former detective chief inspector at the Met, recommended e-bike and e-scooter hire companies, as a condition of operating, be required to pay for the full cost of installation and rental of e-bike bays across the City of Westminster to keep walkways clear.
The retired police officer said: “The culture of impunity which exists in the area around Parliament, Whitehall and Westminster has led to an intolerable and dangerous situation for disabled people which cannot be permitted to continue.”
A UK parliamentary spokesman said: “It is vital that Parliament is accessible to all. We understand that there is more to be done to ensure that disabled people do not face unnecessary difficulties when working in or visiting Parliament. We are committed to making further essential adjustments and ensuring that all our staff are trained in disability awareness.
“Parliament works with a number of organisations – including the Metropolitan Police Service, Westminster City Council and TFL – to ensure access to Parliament is maintained for everyone during periods of change and/or disruption. The safety and security of all those who visit or work in Parliament remains our top priority.”
Extinction Rebellion spokesman Richard Ecclestone, a former police officer, said that no complaints were received about The Big One demonstration.
He said: “Extinction Rebellion and the over 200 supporting organisations who attended The Big One in April to protest at the seat of power worked tirelessly to ensure the activities were inclusive and accessible. They were.”
Mr Ecclestone, also an ex-Army officer, said: “Numerous liaison meetings were held with the Metropolitan Police in advance, and a 24/7 line of communication maintained throughout the four days of protest.
“Access to the Parliamentary Estate was assured at all times with hundreds of stewards on hand to provide assistance to anyone that needed help. No complaints were received from the community or the Parliamentary estate by the Metropolitan Police about the protest.”
He invited anyone who was “impeded from accessing” Parliament during the demonstrations to contact the campaign group so it can “learn any lessons for future protests”.
Paul Dimoldenberg, Westminster City Council’s cabinet member for city management, responding to the report’s criticisms of its approach to dealing with discarded e-bikes and e-scooters, said: “Badly parked e-bikes are a blight on Westminster’s streets and the council has taken decisive action to tackle this problem.
“In August last year, the council began seizing bikes that we believed to be an imminent risk to public safety. We have consistently pushed for harsher fines and the introduction of no-parking zones, and we’re pleased that the bike companies have made these changes.”
The councillor said the local authority had called on the Government to “introduce new legislation so local authorities can regulate these e-bikes and keep pedestrians safe”.