Just 1 per cent of small-boats migrants sent back since 2020
Over half of the 1,182 migrants returned were Albanians, due to the country being deemed safe in UK law
Support truly
independent journalism
Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.
Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.
Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.
![Louise Thomas](https://static.independent.co.uk/static-assets/support-us/louise-thomas.png)
Louise Thomas
Editor
Just one per cent of small boat migrants who have arrives in the UK since 2020 have been returned to their home country, the Home Office’s top official has said.
In a letter to MPs, Home Office permanent secretary Sir Matthew Rycroft said that, since 2020, just 1,182 people who arrived on small boats across the Channel had been sent home. That compares with a total of more than 111,800 who arrived in that time period.
The majority of those returned were Albanian – a country with which the UK has a bespoke agreement – while only 420 who were sent back to other countries.
The numbers sparked outrage from Tory deputy chairman Lee Anderson, who used a session with immigration ministers Michael Tomlinson and Tom Pursglove to ask: “Is that an acceptable figure?”
Illegal migration minister Mr Tomlinson told him: “I want to see those figures as high as possible … as far as I’m concerned the numbers need to be significantly higher than they are.”
It came as Sir Matthew revealed that £22 million of taxpayers’ money is being spent on the Bibby Stockholm asylum accommodation barge.
Also in his letter to the Home Affairs Committee chairman Dame Diana Johnson, Sir Matthew said the “vessel accommodation services” portion of the Bibby Stockholm contract with CTM, which relates to the barge, was £22,450,772.
The vessel is being used to house asylum seekers is moored in Portland Port, Dorset.
![](https://static.independent.co.uk/2023/12/12/19/Bibby%20Indycomp%20News.jpg)
Sir Matthew said the assessment of whether the vessel offered value for money was “currently being updated”. The figure emerged days after an asylum seeker was found dead on the vessel.
South Dorset MP Richard Drax described the news as a “tragedy born of an impossible situation” and said he had been told by the Home Office that the man was thought to have taken his own life.
Immigration delivery minister Tom Pursglove said the cost was “undoubtedly” cheaper than housing asylum seekers in hotels.
Dame Diana said she was “just flabbergasted that a value-for-money assessment was not carried out at the time that the contract was let”.
Mr Pursglove told her it was being “updated” and added: “This is undoubtedly a more cost-effective way of providing accommodation.”
The £22,450,772 figure was contained in a variation to the contract with CTM – worth almost £1.6 billion over two years – to provide hotels and travel for asylum seekers.
As well as the payment to CTM for providing accommodation services on Bibby Stockholm, the government is also paying Dorset Council £3,500 per occupied bed on the vessel, which can hold up to 504 migrants.
![Rishi Sunak has promised to ‘stop the boats’](https://static.independent.co.uk/2023/12/13/00/7317517778cc5a4d0693844a4e835a41Y29udGVudHNlYXJjaGFwaSwxNzAyNTExMjQz-2.74787297.jpg)
The council has also received almost £380,000 in a one-off grant to help support local charity and voluntary organisations provide services on board.
The immigration ministers were also involved in a tetchy clash with SNP MP Alison Thewliss over children who had gone missing while their asylum claims were processed.
Earlier this year it emerged 154 children were missing, that figure had now come down to 132.
Mr Pursglove said there were no unaccompanied asylum seeking children in hotels now but 132 were “still missing” and “we are working intensively” with local authorities and police on the issue.
Ms Thewliss told him: “You’re not doing a very good job of it if 132 out of 154 are still missing… you don’t care do you?”
Mr Pursglove said that was a “pretty outrageous suggestion”.
Today's admissions from the Home Office show the truly appalling scale of Tory failure and chaos, including a disastrously low level of enforcement in the asylum system
The committee heard that of those missing, 103 were now adults and 29 were still under 18.
Shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper said: “Today’s admissions from the Home Office show the truly appalling scale of Tory failure and chaos, including a disastrously low level of enforcement in the asylum system.
“Just 1% of small boat arrivals since 2020 have been removed. Even for Albania, which is a designated safe country, only 5% have been removed – which is a shockingly low figure.”
She said it was a “disgrace” that the unaccompanied children were still missing and the £22 million for Bibby Stockholm was an “eyewatering” figure.
“We can’t continue with this damaging and costly chaos,” Ms Cooper said.
Mr Pursglove also told MPs he was “confident” the Home Office would meet Rishi Sunak’s target to clear the backlog of so-called “legacy” asylum cases – applications made before June 28 2022 – by the end of the year.
“I believe we will fulfil it and I also believe we will see these grant rates come down”, he said.
During the session he was repeatedly asked if the Government was committed to a deadline set to produce a report on what safe and legal routes were available to asylum seekers, as well as any proposed new ones.
The questions came after Cabinet Office minister Esther McVey earlier this month appeared to disparage the idea the Government could create new safe and legal routes for migrants.
Appearing on BBC Radio 4’s Any Questions, she said: “When you talk about safe routes … that actually means more people will be coming here, if you offer up safer routes.
“We are taking down immigration.”
Committee member Tim Loughton – a Tory backbencher who backed the amendment to the act – reminded Mr Pursglove that the Government was under a legal duty under the Illegal Migration Act to lay the safe and legal routes report before Parliament in January.
The minister offered little detail but said: “In letter and in spirit, that agenda is being taken forward.”
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments