Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

In just a flash on the fifth of November, 800 years of Parliament is consigned to oblivion

Kim Sengupta
Saturday 06 November 1999 00:00 GMT
Comments

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

It took just seven minutes on the anniversary of Guy Fawkes to change 800 years of history at the House of Lords.

It took just seven minutes on the anniversary of Guy Fawkes to change 800 years of history at the House of Lords.

It ended not with a bang but rather a steady hum of outrage from the hereditary peers as they made their final exit from the place they had assumed would be theirs for generation after generation.

Their lordships had their first exposure to the electoral process, albeit in a limited way and involving just fellow peers. But they did not like even this one little bit. The grumbling as they trooped out of the chamber, heads bowed over tightly knotted regimental and old school ties, was about the sheer unfairness and folly of it all, the politics of envy of New Labour.

The mood inside their lordships' house on this historic day was at first quite melancholy, like the last day of the last term at college, with the knowledge that many of them would not be seeing each other again. The red benches on either side were not quite full - many had chosen to stay away, including the Earl of Burford, who had been evicted after a second transgression on Thursday. A trio of officials kept a wary eye on the mace.

It was the last debate in the Lords in its present form and Charles Alan Andrew, the Earl Cathcart, Eton and Scots Guards, was making his first and last speech. It was about wind, or gaining power from renewable energy. Within two hours he had discovered his own family's place will not be renewed: after all, he had come 63rd in the poll.

Michael Davies, the Lords Chief Clerk, began to read the list at a brisk pace, as if wanting to get it over with as soon as possible. One by one the casualties were revealed, great aristocratic names like Earl Alexander of Tunis, and Viscount Trenchard, the Viscount Masserene and Ferrard and Lord Sudeley.

There were whispered congratulations for those elected, the Earl Ferrers, Lord Strathclyde, Lord Moynihan, Viscount Astor. Among the first to go and shake their hands, and pat their shoulders was Lord Archer of Weston-Super- Mare, his own eyes on another election in the future.

The numbers were being reduced from 750 by almost 90 per cent and the casualties began to mount.

Some had been earnest in their pleas, like Lord Monk Bretton: "I see it as duty that one should offer to serve." Others showed a certain insouciance, such as Earl De La Warr. "Attendance record: poor. Reason: full-time job in the City; not lack of interest".

Lord Catto, who said he had considered it "morally wrong, purely from the accident of birth to presume to become a member of a legislative assembly" despite sitting in the Lords for 40 years, had now offered himself for selection. He came 79th. Their lordships obviously did not like this Damascene conversion.

The famous media lords also fell: Lord Beaverbrook and the Viscount Rothermere, who had talked about how his chairmanship of the Daily Mail and General Trust gave him "unique insight into the age of technological convergence". He had told his journalistic staff to provide details of the election as soon as possible.

In the ballot 75 hereditaries were voted to stay on as part of the Weatherill deal, as part of the 92 who will remain under the House of Lords Bill. The group will be made up of 42 Tories, 28 cross-benchers, three Liberal Democrats and two from Labour.

After the vote their lordships were ruminating about the mysteries of the franchise as they trooped out. "This is a rather peculiar way of going about things," said one. Another just muttered "It's a farce."

Among the defeated, Lord Monk Bretton was sad and apprehensive about the future. "They have opened Pandora's Box and there will be problems in the future".

The Earl of Lauderdale, 88 years old and hobbling on a cane, shook his head. "I shall miss this place, not for my own sake, but for what it stood for ... this is an aggressive encroachment. There are a lot of people here who simply will not know what to do now; it is very sad." With that he walked away.

Lord Strathclyde, leader of the Conservative peers, who had come second in the ballot with 174 votes, said: "For those who won it is not cause for celebration, it is an honour. For those who lost it is no cause for shame."

Lord Palmer, of the Huntley and Palmer's biscuits family, a cross-bencher who won, was keen to point out his was the first family to receive their hereditary peerage for non-political reasons. "And it was not for biscuits either, but for services to the arts. My great-grandfather never made a speech in his time. My grandfather, I think, did make one; it was on biscuits."

But Lord Palmer is still opposed to the reforms. " The real tragedy is that peoples' lives have been shattered. Tony Blair had succeeded in doing what Guy Fawkes failed to do. This will be known as Tony Blair Day."

The public gallery had been busy, including tourists mystified by it all. Robert Fromholtz, from Baltimore, said: "This is all too much. I am just glad I was here to see it. My father was based here during the war flying bombers. He thought the whole Lords thing was strange then; I am just amazed they are still here all these years later for me to see."

The day ended on a poignant note when 67-year-old Lord Montague of Oxford, a Labour life peer, collapsed and died in the chamber soon after the vote. Other peers tried to help but he died soon afterwards.

From some there were dire warnings that the monarchy itself was in danger. Conservative life peer Baroness Trumpington, a minister in the last Tory government said she wanted to say to Tony Blair "Cool it, buddy boy." The Prime Minister was "Cromwell Two ... I would not be in the least surprised if there isn't a tremendous backlash against what is going on at the present time. I think in this country life goes along in a fairly even way. It's not a country that's in tune with tremendous change."

As Mr Davies ended reading his list, Lord Skelmersdale rose from the Tory benches: " This is for me a day of sadness and regret that colleagues old and new are now retiring because the Government has cut the ground from under their feet." The rest of his speech was drowned by the peers shuffling out of the chamber,

One peer said: " I am off to my club for a stiff drink. No doubt they will be abolishing all that soon." Then he stopped: " Look, this is a serious matter. Bagehot said 'The cure for admiring the House of Lords is to go and look at it'. Well, people who bother to do so soon realise what a jolly useful place this was. This government is too arrogant to realise that. Ah, well, it was fun while it lasted."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in