Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

As it happenedended1478198333

Brexit legal challenge: Theresa May needs parliamentary approval to trigger Article 50, High Court rules – as it happened

Historic case hands Parliament opportunity to challenge, or even delay, the process of leaving the European Union

Andrew Griffin
London
,Samuel Osborne,Siobhan Fenton
Thursday 03 November 2016 10:38 GMT
Comments
Gina Miller gives statement after High Court rules triggering article 50 must go through parliament

Your support helps us to tell the story

My recent work focusing on Latino voters in Arizona has shown me how crucial independent journalism is in giving voice to underrepresented communities.

Your support is what allows us to tell these stories, bringing attention to the issues that are often overlooked. Without your contributions, these voices might not be heard.

Every dollar you give helps us continue to shine a light on these critical issues in the run up to the election and beyond

Head shot of Eric Garcia

Eric Garcia

Washington Bureau Chief

The High Court has ruled on whether Theresa May cannot bypass Parliament when she triggers Britain’s exit from the European Union.

Here are the latest updates:

Campaigners have won their High Court battle over Theresa May's decision to use the royal prerogative in her Brexit strategy.

In one of the most important constitutional cases in generations, three senior judges ruled the Prime Minister does not have power to use the prerogative to trigger Article 50 of the Lisbon Treaty to start the UK's exit from the European Union - without the prior authority of Parliament.

The ruling against the Government was made by Lord Chief Justice Lord Thomas, sitting with two other senior judges in London.

The Government has been given the go-ahead to appeal against the ruling at the Supreme Court.

Judgment: R (Miller) -V- Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union

Judgment: R (Miller) -V- Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union

Unless overturned on appeal at the Supreme Court, the ruling threatens to plunge the Government's plans for Brexit into disarray as the process will have to be subject to full parliamentary control.

Government lawyers had argued that prerogative powers were a legitimate way to give effect "to the will of the people" who voted by a clear majority to leave the European Union in the June referendum.

But the Lord Chief Justice declared: "The Government does not have power under the Crown's prerogative to give notice pursuant to Article 50 for the UK to withdraw from the European Union."

The Government has been given the go-ahead to appeal against the ruling at the Supreme Court but made no immediate announcement about whether it will.

1478177880

Scottish MPs are still preparing their lifeboat to escape the "doomed liner" of Brexit, according to the SNP, despite the ruling.Pete Wishart told MPs that those living north of the border do not plan to go "to the deeps with this stricken Government".He mocked ministers with nautical-themed jokes after Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson insisted the UK will make a "Titanic" success of leaving the EU.With a majority of Scots backing Remain at June's referendum, SNP Commons leader Mr Wishart said: "It's little wonder that the Foreign Secretary refers to this process and compares it to the Titanic."Because what we have is a stricken, doomed liner going to the bottom of the ocean taking its captain with it."I can tell you Mr Speaker, we and Scotland are preparing our lifeboat to get out of this because there's no way we're going to the deeps with this stricken Government."Commons Leader David Lidington replied: "You are trying to work yourself up into a sense of rage that I'm afraid I do find wholly synthetic."

Andrew Griffin3 November 2016 12:58
1478178306

Mark Carney has been speaking as he announces the Bank of England's growth forecasts and that he won't be changing interest rates.He said during that separate press conference that the new High Court ruling was "an example of the uncertainty that will characterise this process".

Andrew Griffin3 November 2016 13:05
1478178659

Gina Miller, the London-based investment fund manager who helped bring the legal challenge, is speaking on Sky. She says that Nigel Farage should be more responsible in his rhetoric - and that he should celebrate the win because it protects the sovreignty of parliament

Andrew Griffin3 November 2016 13:10
1478180187

Shadow Brexit secretary Sir Keir Starmer has said the Government must now produce its negotiating plan for MPs to vote on."The Prime Minister was trying to sideline Parliament and the court has now ruled against her and reminded her that Parliament is sovereign, so the Government needs to urgently review its approach and refer this issue to Parliament where it should be debated," he said.Sir Keir told BBC Radio 4's World At One: "Of course there is a mandate for leaving the EU, and we have to accept and respect the result of the referendum."But the terms, and how we leave the EU, are vitally important."He added: "I really don't think that, in light of this ruling, the Government can get away with refusing to disclose its negotiating stance."

Andrew Griffin3 November 2016 13:36
1478180777

The director of the Vote Leave campaign, Dominic Cummings, has said the Article 50 court ruling is "reasonable". 

Samuel Osborne3 November 2016 13:46
1478180956

He added:

Samuel Osborne3 November 2016 13:49
1478181634

Theresa May will discuss the Brexit process with European Commission president Jean-Claude Juncker on Friday.

The phone call will take place at the request of the Prime Minister, Mr Juncker's spokesman told reporters in Brussels.

Asked about the High Court ruling, the spokesman said: "We will not comment on issues that pertain to the internal legal and constitutional order of our member states."

He added: "The Article 50 procedure, as set out in the treaty, requires the consent of the European Parliament for any Article 50 agreement."

The spokesman said all the other members of the EU would like to see a "swift" notification of Article 50 to begin the Brexit process.

"It was not the commission that asked for a swift notification under Article 50," he said. "If memory doesn't fail me, it was all 27 member states that asked for it at the highest level."

The spokesman said it was not a matter for the European Commission to speculate on the impact of the High Court ruling on the timing of Article 50 being triggered.

Samuel Osborne3 November 2016 14:00
1478183194
Samuel Osborne3 November 2016 14:26
1478184113
Samuel Osborne3 November 2016 14:41
1478184897
Samuel Osborne3 November 2016 14:54

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in