Second fertility centre linked to faulty egg-freezing solution
Jessop Fertility, which is run by Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, may also have used the faulty product.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.A second fertility centre may have used a faulty egg and embryo-freezing solution, the fertility regulator has said.
Jessop Fertility, which is based at Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, has been named as a second clinic involved in the incident.
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) said the clinic “undertook a thorough investigation when they first became aware of the issue and contacted and supported any patient affected”.
Dr Jennifer Hill, medical director at Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, said: “We began a thorough patient review as soon as the product recall notice was issued.
“We have robust tracing processes in our laboratories and so we were able to identify that there were 29 people who had eggs or embryos frozen in the period (August 2022) when we used the particular product batch.
“We can confirm that 28 of those did not have the faulty fluid used to freeze their eggs or embryos. The remaining person was contacted at the time and did not require further actions to be taken.”
It comes after Guy’s Hospital in London apologised for a delay in contacting patients affected at its assisted conception unit.
The hospital contacted 136 patients whose chances of having children may have been compromised because of a faulty liquid used to freeze eggs and embryos during fertility treatment.
In February 2023, US firm Cooper Surgical issued an urgent safety notice about its freezing solution, saying that one “lot” of the product “may contain mislabelled vials” which “may impact the viability” of the eggs or embryos.
While we did not know about the potential issue at the time eggs or embryos were frozen, this manufacturing issue may adversely impact the chance of frozen egg or embryo survival during thawing
A spokesman for Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust said that its assisted conception unit (ACU) may have used the product a few months before the warning was issued – in September and October 2022.
The spokesman added: “While we did not know about the potential issue at the time eggs or embryos were frozen, this manufacturing issue may adversely impact the chance of frozen egg or embryo survival during thawing.
“We have contacted all of those affected and apologised for the delay in doing so and any distress this may have caused.
“We are supporting those who may have been impacted, including through our counselling service, and would urge anyone with concerns to speak to us directly via the dedicated phoneline we have set up.”
The fertility regulator confirmed that it is investigating the incident.
Rachel Cutting, director of compliance and information at the HFEA, said: “The HFEA can confirm that this issue is limited to two clinics in the UK: Guys’ and St Thomas’ Assisted Conception Unit, London and Jessop Fertility, Sheffield.
“Our ongoing investigation only relates to Guys’ as we are satisfied that Jessop’s undertook a thorough investigation when they first became aware of the issue and contacted and supported any patient affected.
“The company supplying the product directly to clinics will know exactly where it’s gone through their traceability processes. The company is also obliged to report any problems to the MHRA.
“Any patients likely to have been affected will have been notified by their clinic. We hope this provides reassurance to anyone concerned.”
Egg or embryo freezing are a standard part of fertility treatment.
Some women choose to freeze eggs for fertility preservation so they can have families later in life while others may do so before undergoing medical treatment for conditions such as cancer.
Embryos are routinely frozen after IVF cycles – either to delay treatment for medical reasons or to give couples the option of more treatments in the future.
Catherine Slattery, a specialist group actions medical negligence lawyer at law firm Irwin Mitchell, said: “This is a very worrying incident which could potentially have devastating consequences for women, especially those who have had to go through the physical and psychological impact of cancer treatment.
“We’ve been contacted by a number of women possibly affected and are looking into their concerns further. Some women are based in London and received treatment at Guy’s Hospital, while others are based elsewhere in England and Wales.
“It’s vital that women receive the care and support they may need to get through this difficult time while this incident is investigated further.
“If any failings are identified during the HFEA and MHRA (Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency) investigations, it’s vital that lessons are learned to prevent issues like this arising in the future.”
Sarah Norcross, director of the Progress Educational Trust, added: “It will be distressing for women with frozen eggs to learn that, due to problems outside their control, their eggs may not survive the thawing process.
“When a woman freezes her eggs, time is of the essence. In all cases, the quality of eggs declines upon reaching a certain age. Additionally, in cases where women are freezing eggs for medical reasons – for example, imminent cancer treatment – they will not want their treatment to be delayed.
We need to understand more about what precisely has gone wrong, whether patients at other clinics are affected, and what the relevant regulators – including the HFEA and the MHRA – are doing about it
“If women affected by this incident have undergone medical treatment which has compromised their fertility, then their opportunity to have a biologically related child may have been lost.
“If women affected by this incident had sought to extend their reproductive choices by freezing their eggs, then they too may have lost their best opportunity to have a family, if the quality of their eggs has declined during the period that has elapsed.
“We need to understand more about what precisely has gone wrong, whether patients at other clinics are affected, and what the relevant regulators – including the HFEA and the MHRA – are doing about it.
“We also need reassurance, from regulators and clinics alike, that processes are in place to notify patients in a timely way when things go wrong.”
Cooper Surgical has been approached for comment.