Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Animals at troubled zoo go missing, die or suffer cold and disease, campaigners claim

Fresh probe at ‘UK’s worst zoo’ raises new claims of mistreatment and neglect

Jane Dalton
Sunday 21 April 2024 16:47 BST
Comments
Undercover investigator discovers 'distressed' giraffe being overfed

Your support helps us to tell the story

From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.

At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.

The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.

Your support makes all the difference.

Animals went missing, died and suffered disease because of continued failings at a zoo once dubbed “the worst in the UK”, campaigners say.

An “emaciated” meerkat struggled to find enough food, bear cages were left uncleaned for too long and a baby kangaroo drowned at Cumbria Safari Zoo, it was claimed.

Other kangaroos were thought to have a disease and lemurs were injured because their “overcrowded” enclosures caused aggression, according to Freedom for Animals.

Animals said to suffer from the cold climbed close to heat lamps
Animals said to suffer from the cold climbed close to heat lamps (Freedom for Animals)

An activist for the animal-rights organisation who posed as a volunteer helper at the zoo for nearly a year found what they said was a “shocking” string of animal-welfare guideline violations, including “appalling” conditions, mistreatment and neglect.

Bosses at the zoo near Dalton, which is thought to house about 1,000 animals, insist they have no concerns over the work of their vets, who are “unrivalled” in their field. They also claim much of the video “pieces together snapshots in time, many pre-dating” their running of this zoo.

In 2013, a keeper at the site, then called South Lakes Safari Zoo, was mauled to death by a tiger, leading to a fine of £297,500 with costs for health and safety breaches.

Four years later, a council report revealed 486 animals had died between 2013 and 2016.

Barrow Council refused to renew the zoo’s licence after inspectors raised concerns, but a firm formed by the staff took over managing the site and the council granted Cumbria Zoo Company Ltd a licence.

A keeper said a kangaroo died, possibly of a disease linked to stress, poor diet or contamination
A keeper said a kangaroo died, possibly of a disease linked to stress, poor diet or contamination (Freedom for Animals)

But concerns remained, and in 2022 a report by wildlife charity the Born Free Foundation concluded that the zoo overfed giraffes, left sloths out in the cold and confined rhinos to tiny stalls.

Now Freedom for Animals, which carried out a fresh investigation, says nothing has changed, despite the change of ownership.

The group claims a missing baby kangaroo was found drowned in a lake – described as “an unforgivable fatality that could have been avoided”.

A keeper was secretly captured on film talking of how one kangaroo had died, possibly of “lumpy jaw”, a bacterial disease linked to stress, poor diet or faecal contamination at feeding stations.

Overcrowding caused by aggression led some lemurs to attack others, it was said
Overcrowding caused by aggression led some lemurs to attack others, it was said (Freedom for Animals)

The campaigner investigating also filmed an “emaciated meerkat struggling to find food and warmth in its enclosure”, and its tail appeared injured.

Meerkats in pens that were said to be cold and draughty were filmed huddling together under heat lamps for warmth.

It was too difficult to get Andean bears out of their enclosure to clean it, another worker was recorded saying, and they added: “We’re trying to do it every other day because this pair are a pain in the arse.”

As a result, the cages – shared by lemurs – got dirty with waste very quickly, it was claimed.

And in one case mouldy food in those cages was left rotting, the footage suggested.

According to one keeper, a lemur was presumed to have frozen to death after failing to return indoors overnight.

A giraffe was filmed twisting its neck unnaturally
A giraffe was filmed twisting its neck unnaturally (Freedom for Animals)

Lemur mothers often abandoned their babies, while overcrowding caused by aggression led some to attack others, keepers were recorded admitting.

Some suffered injuries that required stitches, and one keeper said: “They’ve got big teeth so they do a fair bit of damage to each other.”

Freedom for Animals questioned why the zoo was still breeding them in an “already overcrowded environment that is clearly causing significant illness and injury”.

One lemur, called Bruce, vanished regularly, the campaigner said, after filming a keeper hunting in trees for the animal. A keeper said another lemur found dead “had stuff on his liver”.

Footage showed visitors feeding a giraffe on what the activists said was more than 300 pieces of carrot – a high-sugar food not in the animal’s natural diet. The giraffe was later filmed twisting its neck unnaturally.

Outdoor baboons were kept in for nearly five days in a row
Outdoor baboons were kept in for nearly five days in a row (Freedom for Animals)

Carrot-feeding is arranged twice a day, every day, according to the investigators.

It was also claimed flood damage to an electric fence left baboons, who normally spend most time outdoors, locked inside for almost five days.

The undercover investigator said one keeper told how the baboons’ housing was so “grim” that the animals chewed at the wooden walls.

The council, which issues zoo licences, has previously raised some of the concerns.

Freedom for Animals wants all the animals moved to sanctuaries.

A worker said it was too difficult to get Andean bears out of their enclosure to clean it
A worker said it was too difficult to get Andean bears out of their enclosure to clean it (Freedom for Animals)

“It is appalling that animals in this country are being treated this way and is a gross breach of the Animal Welfare Act and the Zoo Licensing Act,” a spokesperson said.

Karen Brewer, chief executive of Cumbria Zoo Company Limited, said: “The organisation making these allegations is anti-captivity by nature. We continue to welcome feedback, advice and guidance from those qualified to comment on the way in which the zoo is run.

“We are aware of a video now in circulation that pieces together snapshots in time, many pre-dating our running of this zoo, as do many ‘facts’ that surface in these reports.

“We have no concerns over the standard of veterinary care given to the animals who reside with us. Our veterinary team are internationally recognised and unrivalled in their field.”

The Independent has asked Barrow Council to comment.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in