Charity refutes Johnny Mercer claim food bank use is a ‘choice’
Trussell Trust said food banks are a ‘last resort’ for an ‘overwhelming majority’ of people
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.A Foodbank charity has said the service is a “last resort” for the “overwhelming majority” of people, despite Conservative MP Johnny Mercer claiming people ‘choose’ to use them.
The Veterans Minister has claimed it’s “not correct” that people are forced into using food banks, appearing to suggest that some members of the armed forces are going to them because of personal budgeting decisions they’ve made.
But countrywide charity and food bank provider Trussell Trust, which has a branch in Plymouth where Mr Mercer is MP, said most people use food banks only when they have exhausted all other avenues.
The charity’s landmark research, published last week, found most people turn to food banks because they are experiencing hunger and their income does not cover the cost of essentials.
Speaking on Sky News on Tuesday, Mr Mercer, who is a former British Army captain, defended military pay levels.
He said: “These are personal decisions around how people are budgeting every month.”
The MP continued: “I don’t want to see anyone using food banks, of course I don’t. But we’re in an extremely difficult time around cost of living.
“I’ll always advocate for service personel to get paid more, I’d be mad not to. But it has to be within the constraints of a budget.”
Helen Barnard, director of policy, insight and research at Trussell Trust, told The Independent: “Right now, across the UK, millions of people are struggling with hunger and this is not right.
“People are forced to turn to food banks because they are experiencing hunger and their income does not cover the cost of the essentials.
“People are being forced to make choices but they are impossible ones, such as whether to heat or eat, and these are decisions that no one should have to make.”
When it was put to him on Sky News that people do not choose to rely on food banks, Mr Mercer said: “Well in my experience that is not correct.”
He continued: “I think there are some dire cases that we need to do more to wrap our arms around and make sure there is a safety net for people.
“I don’t think food bank use is an accurate portrayal of where levels of poverty, relative or absolute poverty, are in this country.”
The MP for Plymouth Moor View took to Twitter after the negative reaction to his comments. He said: “Enjoying the collective bed-wetting on this. Military personnel should not be using food banks - period.
“Disagree if you like, but that is true. If you are serving personnel and you are using a food bank because you are ‘starving’ please do call me and I will come and see you.”
Mr Mercer appeared on Sky News to talk about a new dedicated helpline for homeless veterans.
He added: “There is no need for a veteran to be sleeping rough and I don’t want to see anyone sleeping rough by the end of this year.”
Ex-servicemen and women can be referred to a network of support, including housing providers, charities and local authorities, by calling the Government-funded hotline
The £500,000 helpline – open to people in England, Scotland and Wales – is part of a two-year £8.55 million programme working towards the Government’s pledge to end veteran rough sleeping.
The aim under the Veterans’ Strategy Action Plan 2022-24 was to achieve that within the current Parliament, but the Government said that with the funding the target can be achieved ahead of schedule
The latest Combined Homelessness and Information Network (Chain) report published last week stated that 5% of people seen rough sleeping in 2022/23 in London had served in the armed forces at some point in their lives.
Some 2% (119 people) of those seen rough sleeping in the year from April 2022 to March 2023 were UK nationals who have served in the armed forces, the report stated.
Guidance has also been published on the Government website setting out the housing options and support available to veterans, service leavers and their families in England, including routes into both veteran-specific and civilian housing.
The Government said the £8.55 million is separate from the £20 million Veteran Capital Housing Fund announced in the Spring Budget.
Last year, food banks in the Trussell Trust network distributed almost three million parcels, including a million for children, and more than 760,000 people accessed support for the first time.
Ms Barnard added: “Food banks are not the answer when people are going without the essentials in one of the richest economies in the world.
“We need a social security system which provides protection and the dignity for people to cover their own essentials, such as food and bills.”
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments