Restaurant forced to pay compensation after blind man refused entry

John Hardy was told that having his dog, Sidney, in the restaurant would be “unhygienic”

John Hardy said being told he could not stay in the restaurant with his guide dog was ‘embarrassing’ (Brian Bateman / SWNS)

An Indian restaurant has been forced to pay £2,000 to a blind man who was refused entry for a family meal due to having a guide dog.

John Hardy was told that having his dog, Sidney, in the establishment would be “unhygienic” and refused him entry.

As the situation intensified, the staff member began only to speak to John’s son rather than him, which upset him.

As a result of the “embarrassing” conversation, he and his wife, son and granddaughter decided to leave Bengal Spice in Williton, Somerset, in September 2021.

Under the Equality Act 2010, restaurants and other service providers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments to avoid putting people with disabilities at a substantial disadvantage.

A guide dog is classed as a reasonable adjustment under the Act.

After taking legal advice and speaking to the Royal National Institute of Blind People (RNIB), the 66-year-old launched a lawsuit.

John said: “I tried to explain that I was blind and Sidney was a guide dog but he wouldn’t listen and said it was unhygienic to have a dog near the kitchen.

“I eat out quite a bit and everybody knows Sidney locally, but when you walk into somewhere new, you are anxious and hyper-aware, wondering if you will have to present your argument and explain why a guide dog is allowed into a restaurant.”

Sidney was banned from the restaurant because staff said having a dog there was ‘unhygienic’ (Brian Bateman / SWNS)

Following a one-day hearing at Taunton County Court last month (December 2022) in which the judgement was awarded in Mr Hardy’s favour, he was awarded compensation of £2,000 which the restaurant must pay.

The legal team was led by Simmons’ international head of dispute resolution partner, Emily Monastiriotis, working with disputes and investigations associate Emily May, supported by senior contract Lawyer Christopher Chipperton and trainee solicitor Lowri Rutter.

Emily Monastiriotis, partner and international head of disputes resolution, said: “We are really pleased to have assisted Mr Hardy in successfully bringing a claim in respect of the discrimination he encountered on this occasion but we are aware of the ongoing discrimination faced by people living with a disability.

“We hope this sends a strong message that discrimination is unacceptable and reminds businesses of their obligations under the Equality Act 2010.”

The restaurant must pay £2,000 to Mr Hardy after he was refused entry for a family meal due to having a guide dog (Brian Bateman / SWNS)

Anita Marshall, specialist lead in RNIB’s legal rights service, said: “Unfortunately, cases of guide dog refusals like John experienced continue to be far from unusual, with restaurants and other service providers often oblivious to or ignoring the legislation.

“We were pleased to be able to work with Simmons & Simmons to bring this case and to see John vindicated in the judgement.

“Our Legal Rights team works tirelessly to challenge discrimination including access refusals and would encourage blind and partially sighted people to report incidents and challenge discrimination wherever it occurs.”