Sergeant who closed stalking probe admits ‘errors’ before Gracie Spinks killing
Sgt Matthew Adams said he felt it was ‘fine’ to close the investigation based on the information he had at the time, an inquest has heard.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.The sergeant who closed the stalking investigation concerning a man believed to have fatally stabbed Gracie Spinks four months later admitted the crime report he used to make that decision was “not very good”, an inquest has heard.
Ms Spinks, 23, reported Michael Sellers to Derbyshire Police in February 2021 after continued unwanted attention and an incident where he was seen waiting in a lay-by near where her horse was stabled in January that year.
Sellers is believed to have stabbed Ms Spinks 10 times as she tended her horse at Blue Lodge Farm in Duckmanton, Derbyshire, months later on June 18 2021, before taking his own life.
Sergeant Matthew Adams, who supervised Pc Sarah Parker, the officer who initially investigated the case, gave evidence at day five of the inquest into the death of Ms Spinks at Chesterfield Crown Court on Monday.
Perhaps we would have got him in for a formal interview and progressed things from there
He told the court he had not been directly line-managing the officer at the time because the pandemic had seen a number of officers moved over to the response team, and had known nothing about the stalking investigation until it was sent to him by Pc Parker on February 18 2021 to close.
Pc Parker told the coroner’s court last week that Sellers was given only “words of advice” as Ms Spinks did not support a prosecution.
Sellers had been deemed a “standard” risk because he had not made threats of violence and he was not known to the force previously.
Sgt Adams, who has been with Derbyshire Constabulary for 23 years, said he had a verbal conversation with Pc Parker about the case before he closed it where they discussed the risk Sellers posed to Ms Spinks, but admitted it was an “error” that this was not written down anywhere.
The sergeant accepted that the crime report written up by Pc Parker that he had based his decision to close the investigation on was “not very good” as it lacked detail, and agreed that the officer had “failed” in her duties to “record, retain and reveal” material.
He also told the court that “in hindsight”, a disciplinary file compiled by the e-commerce firm xbite, where Sellers and Ms Spinks worked together, on the apparent killer’s behaviour towards her should have been requested by the police as part of the investigation.
He said: “I wish we had got that file at the time, but without evidence from Gracie it wouldn’t really have progressed any further. I didn’t think it was proportionate.
“Perhaps we would have got him in for a formal interview and progressed things from there.
“I’m not saying it wouldn’t have changed things, I think it would if we had got him in for interview.
“But when Gracie had reported it there had been nothing from Sellers for a month, there had been no contact, she had blocked him on social media.”
When asked by coroner Matthew Kewley how he was satisfied that the risk Sellers posed to Ms Spinks had been considered, Sgt Adams said: “I did have a verbal conversation with Pc Parker which was not recorded and that is an error on my part.
“She discussed safeguarding with Gracie and we felt the risk was relatively low, because there had been no threats or violence.
“I did speak to Pc Parker before closing the case and we discussed everything around the case, we discussed risk, but it was not documented.”
When asked by the coroner if he was not “concerned” at the lack of detail in Pc Parker’s report, Sgt Adams said: “I was aware that Sellers had been spoken to regarding his behaviour and that’s all I needed to know at that point.
“I was aware Pc Parker had that conversation on bodyworn camera but the footage wasn’t downloaded because she went off sick.
“At the time, I had this verbal conversation with Pc Parker but it’s not documented and I can only apologise for that.”
When asked by the coroner if “words of advice” were appropriate, Sgt Adams said it would have been difficult to do anything else because Ms Spinks was not supportive of further action.
He said: “Gracie didn’t want him speaking to – we’re victim-led and where a victim isn’t supportive, we either do nothing or do something positive and in my view, speaking to him was the right thing to do at that point.
“He needed to be told what he was doing wasn’t acceptable as opposed to doing nothing.
“There had been no threats or violence offered, we had no reason to believe speaking to him wasn’t the right thing to do.
“If it came to a point where he made further contact, he could have used the excuse that he didn’t know it was harassment if he hadn’t been spoken to.”
The sergeant also said it would have been “very difficult” to obtain a protection order without evidence from Ms Spinks, but he admitted, when asked by Narita Bahra KC, representing Ms Spinks’ family, that he was unaware he may have been able to get an interim stalking order without her consent.
Sgt Adams said he felt it was “fine” to close the investigation based on the information he had at the time and added that he believed all “proportionate lines of enquiry” had been made.
The inquest continues.