Isle of Man dying Bill not workable, Baroness Finlay tells its parliament
The detail of the Assisted Dying Bill is being debated at the clauses stage.
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Legislation for assisted dying in the Isle of Man is “not workable” in its current form, a palliative care expert has told its parliament.
The detail of wording in the Assisted Dying Bill was being debated on Tuesday, on the second day of its clauses stage.
Campaigners for legal change have previously suggested the island could be the first jurisdiction among the UK, Ireland and the Crown Dependencies of Jersey and the Isle of Man to legislate for assisted dying.
Dr Alex Allinson, the doctor and Member of the House of Keys (MHK) who proposed the Bill, has insisted it is “not a race” and is about getting the law right on a controversial issue.
In the first stage of debate on the clauses stage of the Bill last week, MHKs voted that a person seeking an assisted death should have to be resident on the island for five years instead of one, and that the life expectancy criteria be extended from six months to a year.
The parliament is now considering further elements of the legislation including how a declaration by a terminally ill person of their clear and settled intention to end their own life is assessed and how and by whom assistance to die might be given.
Dr Allinson cited the current wording that a declaration must be witnessed by two registered medical practitioners who are satisfied the decision has been reached voluntarily on an informed basis without coercion or duress.
Baroness Finlay, an expert in palliative care and a peer in the UK House of Lords, was invited to give evidence at Tuesday’s session in the Isle of Man.
I would have to say that I think at the moment, as it's written, it's not workable
She told MHKs she had looked after “many thousands of dying patients over many, many years”, before expressing concern around the wording of proposed legislation.
Baroness Finlay said: “I would have to say that I think at the moment, as it’s written, it’s not workable.
“It does need to be amended. One of the biggest omissions that you have is actually how the assessments are done, because they’re being done behind closed doors by two doctors without really knowing exactly what’s going on.”
She said doctors are unable to ask about bank statements and people’s wills as that is deemed inappropriate, before adding that “coercion we know is missed very often”.
She added that doctors on the Isle of Man “are clearly against this and they want it operated outside of Manx health” as she told MHKs it is “really important that you listen to them”.
In a statement issued last month, the Isle of Man Medical Society (IOMMS) said it has concluded the Bill is “manifestly unworkable in practice, appears to be rapidly forced through with the sole aim of being the first British Isles jurisdiction to legalise, with scant regard to the damaging effects on Manx society and despite an unwilling Manx population”.
An amendment has been proposed by chief minister Alfred Cannan that the Assisted Dying Bill would have to be put to a referendum before becoming law.
Dr Allison described assisted dying as a “serious and extremely important issue”, and said he appreciated the “dedication members have shown throughout the process of bringing this Bill to the House and the contribution from members of our community with all points of view”.
If voted through, the Bill could receive a Third Reading in the House of Keys in summer, before moving onto the parliament’s Upper House.
Campaigners have said if the Bill was to gain Royal Assent next year, assisted dying could potentially be available to eligible Manx residents from 2027.
Next week, the States Assembly in Jersey will debate assisted dying proposals, with a vote then expected on whether to proceed with drawing up legislation.
A Bill was published in March at Holyrood that, if passed, would allow people living in Scotland with a terminal illness to be given help to end their life.
A Westminster Hall debate was held in London last month, after a petition backed by Dame Esther Rantzen – who has spoken out strongly on her support for a change in the law in the UK.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.