Strange 5,000-year-old clay bowls linked to rise and fall of one of world’s earliest governments

Bowls likely used to provide communal meals millennia ago

Dozens of strange clay bowls unearthed at an archeological site dating to the 4th millennium BC in Kurdistan have offered clues to the origin and collapse of the world’s earliest government, according to a new study.

Researchers have been carrying out excavations at Shakhi Kora in Iraqi Kurdistan since 2019, uncovering a sequence of structures spanning several centuries.

The artefacts unearthed at the site suggest it was associated with one of the world’s first cities, Uruk, now located in southern Iraq.

At Uruk sites, archaeologists previously found a large-scale monumental precinct dating to the later 4th millennium BC as well as thousands of clay tablets containing some of the earliest written texts.

Stacks of millennia-old beveled rim bowls (Antiquity)

Now, researchers have found over a dozen simple and roughly made bowls within ancient institutional structures at Shakhi Kora, similar to those uncovered at Uruk and other contemporary sites.

These bowls, according to the new study, published in the journal Antiquity on Wednesday, were used to provide large-scale communal meals millennia ago likely for workers connected to these institutional buildings.

Animal bones and other residues collected and analysed from these bowls suggest the meals may have been hearty meat stews.

Deposits found in other areas suggest parts of the site may have also served a ritual function, archaeologists said.

These findings, according to researchers, suggest the earliest governing institutions emerged partly due to their ability to provide large-scale meals, potentially as payment for labour.

Cooking and serving area to the east of the pillared hall, left, and a storage area to the west (Antiquity)

Scientists also found evidence of the later abandonment of these governing structures “without signs of violent overthrow or environmental stress”, hinting that the people rejected such a centralised governing with top-down control.

“Our excavations at Shakhi Kora provide a unique, new regional window into the development, and ultimately the rejection, of some of the earliest experiments with centralized, and perhaps state-like, organization,” study co-author Claudia Glatz from the University of Glasgow said.

“This reaffirms that top-down, hierarchical forms of government were not inevitable in the development of early complex societies.”

The research also indicates that the rise of powerful, hierarchical governments did not always happen unopposed in early complex societies.

“Local communities found ways to resist and reject tendencies towards centralized power,” Dr Glatz explained.