Gavin Williamson awards £190m contract to French firm behind school meals voucher ‘shambles’

‘The Tories’ use of poorly performing expensive private contractors in the pandemic is a scandal,’ says Lib Dem leader Ed Davey

Both the DfE and Edenred apologised to schools and families for problems and inconvenience in the early stages of the voucher scheme (Gettyimages/iStockphoto)

Education secretary Gavin Williamson approved a £190m contract with the company blamed for "unacceptable delays" in the school meals voucher scheme, it has emerged.

French company Edenred was criticised last year after its website failed to cope with demand during the first lockdown, leaving thousands of parents and teachers unable to access the system. The ASCL teaching union described the scheme’s launch at the start of the pandemic as a “shambles”.

A National Audit Office investigation identified “a range of problems” with Edenred’s administration of the £15 voucher scheme, which resulted in its helpline being bombarded with 3,940 calls from worried parents and teachers in a single day in April.

The House of Commons Public Affairs Committee also questioned whether the contract was value for money, concluding that the Department for Education (DfE) "missed potential opportunities to reduce the cost or share in the profits”.

While the DfE acknowledged that Edenred initially had “insufficient capacity to meet demand”, it claimed that "performance steadily improved as the scheme progressed" and stated that it had improved the terms of the contract "to ensure the better value for money for taxpayers".

That scheme finished in August last year, but in January the DfE announced it had launched a new scheme with Edenred for the third lockdown.

However at that time it did not reveal the value of the three-month contract, which was eventually published on the government website earlier this week. It states that the value is up to £190m and that it ends on 8 April.

Lib Dem leader Ed Davey told the Guardian the  government was “addicted to wasting taxpayers’ money on bad contracts with private firms, while refusing to pay our NHS and care staff properly”.

He also tweeted: “The Tories’ use of poorly performing expensive private contractors in the pandemic is a scandal, in sharp contrast to the heroic performance of the NHS and so many councils."

Edenred said in a statement to The Independent that the scheme "has been delivered at no cost to the taxpayer over and above the money paid for each free school meal".

The company added: "The insinuation that the Free School Meals contract has wasted taxpayer’s money is completely false.

"Over 95 per cent of parents have said they are satisfied with the scheme - a figure which has been consistent since the early launch issues were resolved last spring. In addition, every pound spent by the DfE has been converted into the equivalent value of vouchers for families."

Edenred said that by 3 March more than £90m worth of voucher codes had already been redeemed into supermarket gift cards for families.

The DfE said it would not be making any further comment.