Poorer children still lagging behind ‘at same rate as decade ago’

Disadvantaged pupils fall further behind in primary schools and at GCSE, Fair Education Alliance says

The attainment gap is now at its highest level since 2012 in primary schools and at GCSE, the report says (iStock)

Poorer students are lagging behind their peers at the same rate as they were a decade ago, a report on the long-standing attainment gap has found.

Disadvantaged pupils have fallen further behind in primary school and at GCSE as progress towards more equal outcomes has slid backwards, the annual research found.

They were at their furthest point behind better-off peers at these stages since 2012, according to the Fair Education Alliance, a coalition of 250 groups that aim to tackle inequality within education.

It said the Covid pandemic served as a barrier to progress being made to narrow the attainment gap, with the cost of living crisis now risking making the situation even worse.

Have you been affected by this story? Get in touch with zoe.tidman@independent.co.uk

The attainment gap has long been an issue in the UK, with wealthier pupils generally tending to do better in school than their more disadvantaged peers.

The Fair Education Alliance published its annual report on educational inequality on Wednesday, offering an assessment on how the attainment gap stands in 2022.

It found the divide between disadvantaged pupils and their peers has widened in maths, writing and reading at primary school due to disruption caused by the Covid pandemic, which sent students home for months at a time, and was now at its widest point since 2012.

Similarly, the attainment gap at GCSE was at its highest point in the past decade. The Fair Education Alliance said this could be down to major policy changes to per-pupil funding and the limiting of subject choice at GCSE.

The regional attainment gap which sees students from London outperform others was also widening, the report said. In this year’s GCSE results, the divide between the proportion of students getting top grades between the north and south grew.

Concerns were also raised over the regional divide in A-level results this year. The Fair Education Alliance said it had grown between regions such as high-performing London and the northeast.

The Fair Education Alliance “report card” also said young people from low-income families, or who have special educational needs or disabilities, have failed to recover from the Covid pandemic at the same rate as their peers.

Gina Cicerone, its chief executive, said: “This sobering research reveals that the gap between young people from low-income backgrounds and their wealthier peers is still as wide as it was a decade ago, and will get wider without urgent action.”

“Education is key to achieving a prosperous society with a strong economy, safe communities and healthy citizens, but schools cannot achieve this alone. We need investment now to give all children and young people a fair education, and to drive Britain’s success as a nation.”

The Fair Education Alliance made a series of recommendations, including targeted spending towards schools and pupils who need it most in the cost of living crisis, and to extend the free school meals scheme to all families on benefits.

The Independent’s Feed the Future campaign is also calling on the government to expand its eligibility criteria to support all children in poverty with free school meals.

Natalie Perera from the Education Policy Institute think tank said: “In the early part of the decade leading up to 2020, the disadvantage gap was closing for both primary and secondary pupils. In the latter part of the decade, progress in closing the gap slowed down and then stalled completely.”

The Fair Education Alliance trustee said a “number of plausible reasons” could be behind the stall in progress, including an increase in child poverty and real-term cuts to school funding.

Nick Brook from the school leaders’ union NAHT said: “Children and young people from the poorest families were hit hardest by the impact of Covid. As this report shows, disruption caused by the pandemic has stripped away the hard-won progress of the last decade by returning attainment gaps to 2012 levels.”

He added: “With families now facing a cost of living crisis this winter that will once again disproportionately affect the poorest, the government cannot continue to sit back and abandon vulnerable children. They must find more money for education, children and young people in this autumn statement.”

A Department for Education spokesperson said: “We know the pandemic impacted children’s learning, which is why it is so important we continue to deliver our £5bn education recovery programme – with over two million tutoring courses started so far - to help pupils get back on track and stay on track.

“We are also supporting teachers to help children and young people to recover from the emotional impact of the pandemic, including by offering training to senior mental health leads in every state school and college by 2025.

“Despite the impact of Covid, there are now more 18-year-olds from disadvantaged backgrounds going to university than ever before, whilst the proportion of young people not in education, employment or training remains one of the lowest on record.”