A Sunday spin in the suburban jungle
The revised Vauxhall Frontera may be little more than a plaything, but Roger Bell is impressed by the 4 x 4's lively ride and keen price; ROAD TEST
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Compared with ordinary cars, 4 x 4 off-roaders such as the Vauxhall Frontera are slow, heavy, thirsty, uncomfortable, cumbersome and expensive - lousy for everyday transport. Yet the Frontera is Europe's best-selling recreational vehicle and the number two 4 x 4 (behind Land Rover's Discovery) in Britain.
Just looking the part of a butch off-roader, even though rarely asked to play the role, counts for a lot. In contrast to the Frontera, Ford's rival Maverick is a slow-selling saloon on stilts that sends out the wrong messages to impressionable buyers.
Despite its many shortcomings, I could tolerate the Isuzu-based, Luton- built Vauxhall Frontera more than most competitors, especially after recent extensive revisions. New engines - a 2.8-litre Isuzu turbo-diesel (replacing the rough old 2.3) and a 2.2-litre petrol 16-valve twin-cam (which displaces the asthmatic eight-valve 2.4) - give better performance; the petrol estate now does l00mph and accelerates with the verve of a 1.3 hatch. The diesel feels quite lively, too, especially in the short-wheelbase Sport which is less roomy than the elongated Estate, but much better proportioned. Neither is particularly economical: brick-like aerodynamics and tank-like mass militate against frugality as well as performance, though Vauxhall talks of class-leading economy.
The Frontera has always had decent on-road steering and handling, making it more pleasant to drive than most rivals, and a lot less harrowing than some. Although incongruous on a race track, the latest Sport felt perfectly safe and secure when diverted on to one during the test drive. Suspension changes described by Vauxhall as a "complete chassis rethink" were designed to make the ride more comfortable and off-roading easier. By and large they succeed.
For a stiffly sprung 4 x 4 - cart springs have given way to coils - the ride is not at all bad, though it still lacks the pliancy of a family saloon. On the rough, the Sport's tendency to pitch and bounce has been curbed if not eliminated, and ground clearance improved with bigger wheels.
Other notable improvements include up-rated brakes (ABS backed for £700 extra) and the option of air conditioning (for £600). Inside, there's a fiddly immobiliser on the petrol models, and new trim materials all round. Although the rather ugly dash and messy switchgear remain - five wash-wipe switches is four too many - the latest Frontera cabins are far more luxurious than before. Comfortable front seats and a lofty stance - ideal for holiday sight-seeing - go some way to compensate for the jittery ride.
Although the styling's unchanged - why mess with a successful formula? - getting at the Estate's ample luggage deck has been simplified by side- hinging the lower half of the spare wheel-carrying tailgate.
Frontera prices, always keen, now start at £14,295 (£95 down) for the 2.0i Sport, which retains the old 2.0-litre engine. The top 2.8TD estate costs £19,325 - an increase of £660 over the superseded 2.3TD. If you really must have a 4 x 4 off-roader, the Frontera is as good as any for value for money. As for the question of poor reliability: Vauxhall insists it has the problem licked.
SPECIFICATIONS
Vauxhall Frontera Sport 2.8TD, £16,245
Engine: 2771 cc, four-cylinder turbo-diesel; 113bhp at 3600rpm. Transmission: five-speed manual gearbox, normal and low ratios, part-time four-wheel drive. Performance: 0-60mph in 14.9 seconds, top speed 93mph, consumption 31mpg.
COMPARISONS
Chrysler Jeep Cherokee 2.5 Sport, £16,695
Technically dated US Cherokee has sold well in Britain. Lesser four-cylinder 2.5 lacks muscle and refinement of more appealing (but very thirsty) 4.0- litre "six". Looks the part but has soft, soggy handling and limited room. Italian VM engine powers new 2.5 turbo-diesel, from £18,195. Wrangler less civilised, more fun.
Ford Maverick 2.7TD, from £15,585
Slow-selling Maverick is Ford's version of the Nissan Terrano 2. Lean, awkward-looking jack-of-all-trades. Lacks butch, fun-car styling of Frontera. Turbo-diesel engine flexible, but performance underwhelming. Five-door roomier, more versatile.
Land Rover Discovery 2.0 three-door, £16,620
Big, butch and not all that expensive. Style and social standing strong, though 2.0 petrol engine of cheapest model lacks low-end muscle. Diesel Frontera quicker, more economical. On-road handling ponderous, off-road ability good. Five-door more versatile.
Toyota RAV4 GX, £14,240
RAV4 is new breed of 4 x 4 with good on-road performance and handling, and limited off-road ability (there are no low-range gears, for instance). Lots of grip, peppy engine, civilised cabin, decent comfort, sensible price. A rising star in the 4 x 4 charts.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments