South Africa vs England: Brad Shields to make first start as Eddie Jones drops Chris Robshaw

Nick Isiekwe joins Robshaw in paying the price for the 42-39 first Test defeat while Danny Cipriani is named on the bench for what could be his first cap in three years

Jack de Menezes

Thursday 14 June 2018 12:51 BST

(Getty)

Brad Shields will make his first start for England in Saturday's second Test against South Africa Rugby after Eddie Jones dropped Chris Robshaw from his entire matchday squad, following the 42-39 defeat last weekend.

The only other change to the starting line-up sees Joe Launchbury return for the encounter in Bloemfontein, having recovered from a calf injury, while Danny Cipriani is named among the replacements.

“Based on South Africa’s likely selection of an extra lineout jumper we have decided to start with Brad Shields, which improves our lineout,” Jones explained of his decision to axe former captain Robshaw. “It is tough on Chris Robshaw as he has been an outstanding player for us but I know he will bounce back.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Show all 30

1/30South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

<b>South Africa:</b> Willie Le Roux – 8 out of 10

Was visibly frustrated with their early struggles, but took his try with a beautiful run that Wasps fans will have found very familiar. Nice pass to release Nkosi for his second, and started to take control the game as the Springboks pulled away from England.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

S’busiso Nkosi – 8 out of 10

Look very much a Test-level wing with two clinical finishes – albeit one that came with a generous slice of luck. His first came with a chip and chase that Daly should have fielded, and his second saw him loop round to the opposite wing and collect a good offload from Dyantyi to go over unopposed. It was also his barrelling run over Ford that led to the first try. Could have had a hat-trick.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Lukhanyo Am – 6 out of 10

His early defensive issues were alleviated when the Springboks started to dominate the ball, as often he proved the miss-out man in attack.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Damian De Allende – 6 out of 10

Very poor tackle from such a big centre allowed Brown to score, but it was his decision to attack the blindside that led to Nkosi’s first try.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Aphiwe Dyantyi – 7 out of 10

Good offload to Nkosi for his second try before bagging one of his own, even if he had to juggle the ball over the line.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Handre Pollard – 7 out of 10

Stepped far too easily by Brown for the opening try four minutes in, but recovered his composure well to start firing his back line on all cylinders and added some very impressive conversions. Despite all the tries, it proved his late penalty that secured the victory.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Faf De Klerk – 9 out of 10

A brilliant return to test rugby as he got the Springboks up and running with their first try. Quickened the pace with tap penalties that caught England on the back foot. Proved his worth to South African rugby and my how they’ve missed him.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Tendai Mtawarira – 6 out of 10

Not able to dominate the scrum and kept fairly quiet in the loose as his teammates stole the headlines. Replaced by Steven Kischoff soon after the break.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Bongi Mbonambi – 7 out of 10

Bit in when defending that isolated Nkosi for Brown’s opening try, but solid in the lineout as he mixed up his target area to keep England guessing. Roared in triumph when the front-row smashed through the English pack.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Trevor Nyakane – 6 out of 10

Unable to get the better of Mako Vunipola in the front-row battle and fairly ineffective with the ball. Replaced by Wilco Louw seven minutes into the second half, who made an immediate impact.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

RG Snyman – 7 out of 10

Beautiful 50m run saw the lock gallop upfield at the start of the second half and he proved a real thorn in the side of the English defence.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Franco Mostert – 6 out of 10

South Africa’s go-to man in the lineout as he jumped well to keep the ball out of Itoje’s mits.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Siya Kolisi – 7 out of 10

Ferocious in defence as he hit opposite number Robshaw on more than one occasion. Also left his mark on his fellow captain Farrell. A good defensive showing.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Jean-Luc Du Preez – 6 out of 10

Unable to cover back in time to stop Brown and gave away a needless penalty for diving off his feet at the start of the game. Replaced by Pieter-Steph du Toit early in the second half and could find his place at risk.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Duane Vermeulen – 8 out of 10

Grew into the game as South Africa started to secure front-foot ball. Enjoyed a strong run out wide early in the second half and proved a real turnover merchant as he disrupted English ball time and time again.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

<b>England:</b> Elliot Daly – 7 out of 10

Got the first points of the game as he took full advantage of the altitude with a 61m penalty, but committed an absolute howler when he missed the ball and allowed Nkosi to score. Scored a try of his own with a neat finish and defensively he put in a huge tackle on Wasps teammate Le Roux that stopped an attack in its tracks, but two sloppy kicks from hand cost England precious ground.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Jonny May – 7 out of 10

Enjoyed a strong start as his early break set-up Brown’s opening score before delivering the final pass to Daly, but spent a lot of the game running backwards and De Klerk and Pollard looked to pin him back.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Henry Slade – 6 out of 10

Very good opening 20 minutes as his footwork dazzled the Springboks’ defensive line, with one sidestep committing two defenders before he produced a love offload from the deck to Brown. Faded as the game went on though as South Africa starved him of ball.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Owen Farrell – 7 out of 10

Linked up well with Ford and was at his consistent best from the tee. Lovely pass to Daly that set-up May’s late try.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Mike Brown – 7 out of 10

Appeared to silence his critics somewhat with a powerful finish as he beat two men to score inside four minutes. Made a second break after Slade’s offload, but kept out of the game by a resurgent Springboks side. Made a good one-handed tackle on Nkosi when he went close and had a late burst as time ticked down.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

George Ford – 6 out of 10

On the end of a rampaging run from Nkosi and defensively he struggled slightly and his kicking from hand was poor. But his attack play was much better than it has been of late.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Ben Youngs – 6 out of 10

Fairly average on his Test return after injury, and while he didn’t do a lot wrong, there were no runs or breaks on his part.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Mako Vunipola – 6 out of 10

Solid in the scrum and was able to show his best with ball in hand, but shown a harsh yellow card for a late tackle on De Klerk.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Jamie George – 6 out of 10

Thrown into the starting line-up with Dylan Hartley absent and he was reliable in the lineout but slightly disappointing in the loose. Will have not liked being shoved back by the South African scrum.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Kyle Sinckler – 6 out of 10

In place as the first-choice tighthead in Dan Cole’s absence. Not used as much as he would have liked in the loose but did a solid job in the scrum until England were shoved backwards, which triggered his replacement by Harry Williams.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Maro Itoje – 6 out of 10

The good and the bad of Maro Itoje was on display. He was the main culprit in conceding penalties as he twice hit De Klerk high and was trapped not rolling away, but wise to spot a chance to score by reaching over the ruck.

Getty

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Nick Isiekwe – 4 out of 10

The sacrificial lamb as Eddie Jones made the decision to replace him with Brad Shields 31 minutes in. Looked distraught as he came off, and consoled by his teammates.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Chris Robshaw – 6 out of 10

Doesn’t carry an impact when running with the ball that allowed the Springboks defenders to knock him backwards. His support play was good, but left isolated when Steven Kitshoff was able to win a penalty for holding on.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Tom Curry – 6 out of 10

Tried to impose at the breakdown but was fighting a one-man battle. Made one eye-catching break in the second half that made all of 35 metres, but departed soon after with a calf injury.

South Africa vs England first Test player ratings

Billy Vunipola – 6 out of 10

One uncharacteristic error as he dropped an early restart, and South Africa looked to double up on him that early on freed up space for his teammates. Otherwise kept fairly quiet, which takes some doing.

“Danny Cipriani will come onto the bench, as we are looking for something a little bit different to finish the game, which he can bring. He’s been training well and doing everything that has been asked of him."

Cipriani replaces Piers Francis, who drops out of the 23 along with the jettisoned Nick Isiekwe. The Saracens forward was sacrificed by head coach Jones just 36 minutes into the first half last week, and he is left out completely this time around as Newcastle Falcons forward Mark Wilson is named on the bench with Shields once again covering the second-row.

Despite letting a 21-point lead vanish during last Saturday’s encounter at Ellis Park, Jones believes that training this week will help his side perfect their preparations for the game – having dismissed suggestions that the players were undercooked to play at altitude in Johannesburg.

“We have come here to win the series against South Africa and the squad is ready to go out and beat them this weekend,” he added. “We have had a very good preparation this week and the intensity and executions in those sessions are going to put us in a good position for Saturday.

“The way the team have come together has been superb. Owen Farrell, with a number of the senior players, has really moulded the squad together. They are working hard to improve their game to make sure we win.

“When you have a win like South Africa did on Saturday you come into the game with a bit of confidence so we have to make sure we dent the Springboks' confidence early. Bloemfontein is a very fast ground at altitude. It has an average of 60 points per Test match so we are anticipating an ebb-and-flow type game like we had in Johannesburg.”

South Africa meanwhile have made two changes in the hope of clinching a series victory with a game to spare. As Predicted by Jones, Pieter-Steph du Toit starts at flanker in place of Jean-Luc du Preez and Frans Malherbe returns at tighthead prop, with Wilco Louw dropping out of the squad.

Teams

South Africa: Willie le Roux; S’busiso Nkosi, Lukhanyo Am, Damian de Allende, Aphiwe Dyantyi; Handre Pollard, Faf de Klerk; Tendai Mtawawira, Bongi Mbonambi, Frans Malberbe; RG Snyman, Franco Mostert; Siya Kolisi, Pieter-Steph du Toit, Duane Vermeulen.

Replacements: Akker van der Merwe, Steven Kitschoff, Thomas du Toit, Jean-Luc du Preez, Sikhumbuzo Notshe, Ivan van Zyl, Jesse Kriel, Warrick Gelant.

England squad to face South Africa

Elliot Daly; Jonny May, Henry Slade, Owen Farrell, Mike Brown; George Ford, Ben Youngs; Joe Marler, Jamie George, Kyle Sinckler; Maro Itoje, Joe Launchbury; Brad Shields, Tom Curry, Billy Vunipola.

Replacements: Luke Cowan-Dickie, Joe Marler, Harry Williams, Mark Wilson, Nathan Hughes, Ben Spencer, Danny Cipriani, Denny Solomona.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies