Ferguson fights to recover confidence
Glenn Moore on the way ahead for Manchester United after a bad 10 days
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.Manchester City fans will have enjoyed it most - Maine Road is where the blue and yellow shirts of Fenerbahce will soon be sported - but they are not the biggest domestic beneficiaries of Manchester United's unexpected Champions' League defeat on Wednesday night.
Liverpool, Newcastle, Arsenal and any other side with pretensions to United's Premiership crown have most reason to be grateful to the Turkish champions. For weeks it has seemed that United have been putting their domestic campaign on the back burner while they concentrate on Europe. Wednesday was supposed to be the night they tied up that adventure until the quarter-finals in March and redirected their attention to the English game.
Instead, they face Chelsea tomorrow, and Arsenal a week later, knowing they have Juventus looming on 20 November. Even a United victory would secure qualification only if Fenerbahce fail to defeat Rapid Vienna at home the same night. United's European fate is thus unlikely to be settled until 6 December, when they travel to Vienna and the Turks to Turin.
"We are still in a better position than Fenerbahce," Alex Ferguson said yesterday. The 1-0 defeat was United's first at home in Europe in 40 years and 57 matches, but the United manager added: "Losing the game was more important than losing the record.
"Some poor soul was going to lose it eventually, it happened to be me. We're not delighted to lose it, but in a way it is a relief. There were times when the team were worrying more abut losing the record than winning matches. Now it is out of the way."
Tomorrow's match against Chelsea has assumed extra importance, however, in the wake of United's loss of confidence. It may seem a daft suggestion but, at present, United might even struggle to beat their First Division neighbours - not City, but Oldham Athletic. Oldham may still be bottom of the First Division, but they have started winning. United are the champions and are bulging with talent and medals, yet they have been losing - and losing badly. As Jordi Cruyff admitted on Wednesday night: "When you've been losing like we have, it eats away at you."
Cruyff is only 22 yet he is older than six of the 14 United players who were involved on Wednesday. United's youthful face, so refreshing, so energising in victory, is a problem in defeat. Confidence is fragile enough in many senior footballers; young men who have little experience of defeat are even more vulnerable and few at United are experienced at losing.
A test then, for Ferguson. There are three solutions to a loss of confidence: change the faces, change the places, or change the routine. He might try them all.
In the aftermath of defeat, Manchester was humming with rumours of an imminent signing. The long pursuit of Miguel Angel Nadal, Barcelona's Spanish international defender, may be nearing an end. However, it is suggested that he will not be arriving at Old Trafford until 15 December, when the Spanish transfer market reopens. In the light of Gary Pallister's injury problems, United may well attempt to speed his release.
United's need for a centre-forward is even more pressing than for a centre- half. Eric Cantona again appeared unhappy playing with his back to goal on Wednesday, but Ferguson's options are limited.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has, understandably, looked jaded recently; Paul Scholes is no more a leader of the line than Cantona, and Andy Cole is injured. Perhaps Jordi Cruyff could have played there, though he does not appear a natural centre-forward either. How United missed an Alan Shearer or a Les Ferdinand.
While he awaits new blood Ferguson can shuffle the pack. Again, options are limited. Phil Neville is back, but Pallister is out and Ryan Giggs will not be fit until the Arsenal game at the earliest. Roy Keane will miss that match through suspension after his dismissal at The Dell.
One other thing Ferguson could do - but will not - is change the captaincy. Cantona has not proved a success in the role. He may have presence, but he is not the inspiration Steve Bruce was, especially when he is struggling with his own game. Yet who else is there? Most of the team are too young or too new. Peter Schmeichel is a possibility, but it is difficult to lead a team from in goal; Denis Irwin is too quiet; David May is unsure of his place. Pallister is the best candidate, but how often will he be fit?
It all makes for a difficult time for Ferguson, but he has come through far worse in his decade at the club. Think of 1990, when his job appeared on the line. Think of last season, when Paul Ince, Andrei Kanchelskis and Mark Hughes had left. United's form is now more than a blip, but it is not yet a crisis. Nor is it likely to become one.
A leading bookmaker yesterday halved its odds from 6-1 to 3-1 that Ferguson will not be United's manager on the final day of the season. William Hill also quoted United at 100-1 to be relegated.
Pallister's operation, page 31
`The record can intimidate foreign teams but it can be intimidating for myself. I do not want to be the manager who loses it. At some point it is going to happen but I hope it is long after I have gone to the great penalty box in the sky and am in peace.'
Alex Ferguson speaking in September about Manchester United's unbeaten home record in European competition.
MANCHESTER UNITED'S HOME RECORD IN EUROPE
1956-57 European Cup
Prelim Anderlecht 10-0 (12-0 agg)
1st rd Borussia Dortmund 3-2 (3-2)
Q-f Athletic Bilbao 3-O (6-5)
S-f Real Madrid 2-2 (3-5)
1957-58 European Cup
Prelim Shamrock Rovers 3-2 (12-0)
1rd Dukla Prague 3-0 (3-1)
Q-f Red Star Belgrade 2-1 (5-4)
S-f Milan 2-1 (2-5)
1963-64 Cup-Winners' Cup
1rd Willem Il Tilburg 6-1 (7-2)
2rd Tottenham Hotspur 4-1 (4-3)
Q-f Sporting Lisbon 4-1 (4-6)
1964-65 Fairs Cup
1rd Djurgarden 6-1 (7-2)
2rd Borussia Dortmund 4-0 (10-1)
3rd Everton 1-1 (3-2)
Q-f RacingClub Strasbourg 0-0 (5-0)
S-f Ferencvaros 3-2 (3-3) lost play-off 1-2
1965-66 European Cup
Prelim HJK Helsinki 6-0 (9-2)
1rd Vorwarts Berlin 3-1 (5-1)
Q-f Benfica 3-2 (8-3)
S-f Partizan Belgrade 1-0 (1-2)
1967-68 European Cup
1rd Hibernians Paola 4-0 (4-0)
2rd FK Sarajevo 2-1 (2-1)
Q-f Gornik Zabrze 2-0 (2-1)
S-f Real Madrid 1-0 (4-3)
*Final Benfica 4-1
1968-69 European Cup
1rd Waterford 7-1 (10-2)
2rd Anderlecht 3-0 (4-3)
Q-f Rapid Vienna 3-0 (3-0)
S-f Milan 1-0 (1-2)
1976-77 Uefa Cup
1rd Ajax 2-0 (2-1)
2rd Juventus 1-0 (1-3)
1977-78 Cup-Winners' Cup
*1rd St Etienne 2-0 (3-1)
2rd Porto 5-2 (5-6)
1980-81 Uefa Cup
1rd Widzew Lodz 1-1 (1-1) lost on away goals
1982-83 Uefa Cup
1rd Valencia 0-0 (1-2)
1983-84 Cup-Winners' Cup
1rd Dukla Prague 1-1 (3-3) won on away goals
2rd Spartak Varna 2-0 (4-1)
Q-f Barcelona 3-0 (5-2)
S-f Juventus 1-1 (1-2)
1984-85 Uefa Cup
1rd Raba ETO Gyor 3-0 (5-2)
2rd PSV Eindhoven 1-0 (1-0)
3rd Dundee Utd 2-2 (5-4)
Q-f Videoton 1-0 (1-1) Iost on penalties
1990-91 Cup-Winners' Cup
1rd Pecsi Munkas 2-0 (3-0)
2rd Wrexham 3-0 (5-0)
Q-f Montpellier 1-1 (3-1)
S-f Legia Warsaw 1-1 (4-2)
*Final Barcelona 2-1
1991-92 Cup-Winners' Cup
1rd Athinaikos 2-0 (2-0)
2rd Atletico Madrid 1-1 (1-4)
1992-93 Uefa Cup
1rd Torpedo Moscow 0-0 (0-0) lost on penalties
1993-94 European Cup
1rd Kispest Honved 2-1 (5-3)
2rd Galatasaray 3-3 (3-3) lost on away goals
1994-95 Champions' League
IFK Gothenburg 4-1
Barcelona 2-2
Galatasaray 4-0
1995-96 Uefa Cup
1rd Rotor Volgograd 2-2 (2-2) lost on away goals
1996-97 Champions' League
Rapid Vienna 2-0
Fenerbahce 0-1
* Played at a neutral venue
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments