Car choice: A Ford Mondeo or a Saab 9-5 estate

Alison Stuart needs a car for a year while she is based in the UK. She has £2,000 to spend

(Free Car Mag)

A car for the head

The safest route would be to go to a car dealer and ensure that the warranty cover is comprehensive. I would also recommend going for a car that is widely available and therefore good value to buy, own, run and resell. For that reason the Ford Mondeo would make an excellent, safe, spacious and affordable family car. Even better, there are plenty to choose from at dealers and used car supermarkets. We found a 2008 2.0 Zetec TDCI with 112,000 miles and just two previous owners on sale at £2,495 with a comprehensive warranty.

(Free Car Mag (Free Car Mag)

A car for the heart

Alison has been offered a Saab 9-5 estate and a Renault Scenic, each for £2,000. I would not recommend the Scenic, but a well looked-after Saab should be excellent. There is lots of room inside a 9-5 for both front and rear passengers. All that goes together well with the very smooth ride, which refuses to be upset, whatever the road conditions. The boot is large and there is plenty of room for a family of four. We found a 2005 2.2 TiD Linear Sport with an automatic gearbox and inclusive labour warranty for £1,795.

If you would like James Ruppert to help with your car choice, email james@freecarmag.com. For more motoring views visit freecarmag.com