The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

15 best mascaras for sensitive eyes that define and lengthen lashes

From hypoallergenic to vegan formulas, these mascaras are gentle on sensitive eyes

Helen Wilson-Beevers
Thursday 02 May 2024 11:54 BST
We looked at wand shapes, lengthening and whether our flutter stayed put
We looked at wand shapes, lengthening and whether our flutter stayed put (The Independent)
Our Top Picks

Mascara is an essential make-up buy, whether you like a natural look or a bolder statement eye. This classic beauty product adds volume, definition and length by gripping, separating and lifting eyelashes. Applying mascara is an effective way to make your face appear more awakened, and it can be added to both top and bottom lashes.

But shopping for mascara can be tricky if you struggle with sensitive eyes, whether that’s because of hay fever, hormonal changes or being particularly prone to irritation. Symptoms of easily irritated eyes include redness, itching, stinging, streaming and general soreness.

It’s safe to say all the above may be exacerbated by make-up products, which is why we’re here to help.

From fragrance-free formulas and soothing ingredients to a weightless finish and contact lens compatibility, there’s no need to compromise on lash-lengthening results simply because of eye sensitivity. We’ve put several mascaras to the test, including vegan-friendly and hypoallergenic buys.

Here’s our rundown of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes, to suit all budgets.

How we tested the best mascaras for sensitive eyes

Our tester has sensitive eyes, and the mascaras included are a list of favourites they’ve been using for several months, as well as newer finds. They looked at wand shapes, lengthening effects and whether the mascara stayed put during a long day’s wear, without causing their easily irritated eyes to stream or sting.

The best mascaras for sensitive eyes in 2024 are:

  • Best mascaras for sensitive eyes overall – It Cosmetics hello lashes+: £25, Boots.com
  • Best buildable formula – Glossier lash slick: £18, Glossier.com
  • Best vegan-friendly buy – Pacifica vegan collagen fluffy lash mascara: £20, Cultbeauty.co.uk
  • Best for lash volume – La Roche Posay toleriane mascara: £19.00, Sephora.co.uk
  • Best affordable buy – L’Oreal lash paradise black mascara: £10.39, Lookfantastic.com

It Cosmetics hello lashes+

It Cosmetics hello lashes+    indybest.jpg
  • Best: Mascara for sensitive eyes overall
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Biotin, argan oil and jojoba
  • Benefits: Length and volume
  • Why we love it
    • Significantly lengthens lashes
    • Didn’t run or make eyes sting
    • Easy to reach tricky inner lashes

This shimmery pink tube is complete with a black textured grip coating, making it easier to hold the wand steady for smooth application. The bendy wand also features a ball tip, meaning we could grip trickier-to-reach inner eyelashes. Lash-nourishing ingredients include biotin, argan oil and jojoba oil, and the formula felt gentle to wear without causing any itchiness.

This is a tubing mascara, so lashes are wrapped in individual tubes of product. As a result, we saw significantly lengthened eyelashes that were spread upwards and outwards, creating a long-lasting babydoll look. Plus, the ophthalmologically tested mascara didn’t run or make our eyes sting when walking in windy weather.

  1.  £25 from Boots.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

Glossier lash slick

Glossier lash slick mascara indybest.jpeg
  • Best: Buildable formula
  • Colour: Black or brown
  • Key ingredients: Biotin
  • Benefits: Water-resistant, even coverage
  • Why we love it
    • Gentle on super sensitive eyes
    • Suitable for contact lens wearers

The sleek minimalist pink tube holds a slimline flexible brush that widens from its precise tip to a thicker base. Fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested, we found the lightweight formula to be gentle on our super sensitive eyes. This mascara gave an easily buildable look, with an eye-widening even coating across each individual lash that lasted all day without flaking. The fact that it’s water-resistant rather than waterproof means removal is easy without any harsh rubbing on irritable eyelids. Complete with conditioning biotin and black pigment highlighting polymers, it’s suitable for contact lens wearers too.

Back to top

Green People volumising mascara

Green People mascara.jpg
  • Best: For wand flexibility
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Sunflower oil
  • Benefits: Lightweight, gentle, separates lashes
  • Why we love it
    • Provides a subtle finish

This certified organic mascara has 98 per cent natural ingredients and is vegetarian. It’s user friendly even when you’re in a rush, and the lightweight formula doesn’t stick together or transfer. Buildable but not overly bold, we felt this pick was best for a no-make-up make-up day – it separates lashes evenly and gives quite a subtle lift. We appreciated its flexible wand head, which wasn’t likely to poke us in the eye. Components such as soothing sunflower oil are notable as the complete product does feel gentle on the eyes and surrounding skin.

Back to top

Chantecaille faux cils longest lash mascara

Chantecaille faux cils longest lash mascara indybest.jpeg
  • Best: Luxury buy
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Rose oil
  • Benefits: Lengthening and conditioning
  • Why we love it
    • Formula contains no parabens

This mascara’s metallic tube has a premium look to match the price point. The brush is of medium thickness, and we felt its soft fibres effectively lengthened and volumised lashes. It also fanned out bottom eyelashes well, and we didn’t experience any clumping or product residue on our eyelids – because of this, you can build it up for a bolder look minus any messiness. The formula contains no parabens and is phthalate and fragrance free. Sensitive eye-friendly ingredients include rose oil, which helps it to feel comfortingly conditioning.

Back to top

Pacifica vegan collagen fluffy lash mascara

Pacifica vegan collagen fluffy lash mascara  indybest.jpg
  • Best: Vegan-friendly buy
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Vegan collagen and plant fibres
  • Benefits: Hydrating, lengthening and volumising
  • Why we love it
    • The wide wand still reaches inner eyelashes without much effort

This vegan-friendly mascara is presented in a dreamy pink and purple ombre glass bottle with minimal branding, and the pretty packaging is recyclable. It has a satisfyingly thick brush that grips and coats lashes with ease. We noticed the wide wand still reaches inner eyelashes without much effort (or risk of poking ourselves in the peepers).

Ingredients include vegan collagen and plant fibres for hydrating lashes. This is a maximum-impact mascara for both lengthening and volumising, suiting contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes. The formula is comfortable to wear, and we could barely feel it was there.

Back to top

Fenty Beauty full frontal volume, lift and curl mascara

Fenty Beauty full frontal volume, lift and curl mascara  indybest.jpg
  • Best: For curling lashes
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Synthetic beeswax and stearic acid
  • Benefits: Lifts, curls and feels lightweight
  • Why we love it
    • Lightweight formula doesn’t feel heavy on lashes
    • Easy to remove

This mascara is packaged in a trendy silver and black metallic bottle and includes a flat brush with wide edges. It works by lifting lashes and adding curl and volume. We noticed visibly lengthened eyelashes without any clumping whatsoever. Looking at our side profile, we could see the satisfying curling effect. The formula is ideal for sensitive eyes because it doesn’t include any ingredients associated with allergic contact reactions. Components include vegan-friendly synthetic beeswax and softening stearic acid.

Our tester noted that this lightweight mascara doesn’t feel heavy on lashes. It’s water-resistant and stays put throughout long days while not being too tricky to remove either.

  1.  £23 from Boots.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

Perricone MD no makeup mascara

Perricone MD no makeup mascara .jpg
  • Best: For lengthening lashes
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Vitamin E and biotin
  • Benefits: Grip, lifts and lengthens
  • Why we love it
    • Gel serum consistency
    • Dries quickly

This fragrance-free mascara has a gel serum consistency, containing biotin and vitamin E for nourishing lashes. The straight brush has tiny bristles that gripped our eyelashes, lifted them from the root upwards, and offered full coverage without stinging our eyes. We found that a single coat creates a lengthening effect, and our tester also saw significant length added to the lower lashes. Plus, it dries quickly.

Although one layer was enough for busy mornings with less time on our hands, we built this look up with extra coats when seeking extra eye make-up drama.

Back to top

Lancome hypnose custom wear volumising mascara

Lancôme hypnôse custom wear volumizing mascara  indybest.jpg
  • Best: For individual lash definition
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Vitamin B5
  • Benefits: Separating, buildable and flake-free
  • Why we love it
    • Suitable for contact lens wearers
    • The slim, wavy wand reaches inner lashes with ease

Suitable for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes, this mascara has a curved tube that is ergonomically shaped and comfy to hold. We found that the slim, wavy wand could reach inner lashes, and our tester saw that it separated and individually defined each lash.

The brush felt soft while being strong enough to add sufficient grip. We also didn’t see any product transfer onto our eyelid or lash line. Even after building up our mascara look with lots of coats, our eyes still felt comfortable during long-lasting wear, and there was no flakiness either.

Back to top

La Roche Posay toleriane mascara

La Roche-Posay Toleriane Volume Mascara 7ml .jpg
  • Best: For lash volume
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Panthenol
  • Benefits: Impressive thickness and strongly pigmented finish
  • Why we love it
    • Delivers voluminous lash results
    • Creates a dramatic eye make-up look with minimum effort

An allergy-tested mascara suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, this is a mid-price mascara that delivers voluminous lash results. The fluffy brush grabs lashes and adds impressive thickness, and we saw a strongly pigmented finish. Because of this intense black coating, our tester noted the mascara creates a dramatic eye make-up look with minimum effort.

Key ingredients include moisturising panthenol, and lashes looked thicker and had noticeable volume, without feeling stiff or uncomfortable. There were no smudges left on skin either, and our tester’s eyes didn’t sting when out in the fresh air. Plus, the formula stayed in place throughout a long day’s wear.

Back to top

La Perla Beauty volumising mascara

La Perla Beauty volumizing mascara .jpg
  • Best: Colourful mascara
  • Colour: Black, brown, blue or dark violet
  • Key ingredients: Organic shea butter
  • Benefits: Soothing and thickening
  • Why we love it
    • Calming ingredients
    • Made our lashes look thicker without feeling weighed down

As mascara buys go, this one is particularly bougie and added a luxury aesthetic to our make-up bag – matching the premium price tag. The mostly gold case has a smaller black cap revealing a curved brush, and the fragrance-free formula is available in black, brown, blue and dark violet. For a subtle splash of eye-brightening colour, we loved the violet shade. In terms of calming ingredients, organic shea butter protects skin from irritation, and our tester’s sensitive eyelashes felt soothed by the ophthalmologically tested formula.

We noticed the brush created an even covering and made our lashes look thicker without feeling weighed down or spiky.

Back to top

L’Oreal lash paradise black mascara

L’Oréal lash paradise black mascara .jpg
  • Best: Affordable buy
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Castor oil
  • Benefits: Softening and volumising
  • Why we love it
    • Soft, thick brush
  • Take note
    • Wand isn’t precise for individual lashes

Presented in a pretty rose gold tube, this mascara has a thick brush that is soft on lashes. The wand isn’t precise for individual lashes, but we didn’t mind this because it creates instant eye-opening volume. Our eyelashes felt supple too, and not at all spiky or tough to touch. This meant they were comfortable throughout the day, and we didn’t find ourselves rubbing or itching our eyes. This is an affordable castor oil-infused mascara that is both kind to eyes and big on lash-thickening.

Back to top

Clinique high impact zero gravity mascara

Clinique high impact zero gravity mascara .jpg
  • Best: Curved brush applicator
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Simmondsia chinensis seed oil
  • Benefits: Soothing and lengthening

This allergy-tested mascara is suitable if you wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes, and it’s been ophthalmologist tested too. Key ingredients include moisturising simmondsia chinensis seed oil. The curved brush mirrors the eye shape, meaning we could grip and lift lashes without much effort. That was a big bonus for us, as too much faffing about with mascara can make our eyes sore. We saw significantly lengthened eyelashes, and the gel mascara formula is soothing to wear. Plus, it stayed put well into the evening.

We used only warm water for removal, which minimised any potential irritation, and the formula gently wiped away.

Back to top

Mii superboost lash lover two-in-one conditioning and growth boosting serum mascara

Mii superboost lash lover 2-in-1 conditioning & growth boosting serum mascara .jpg
  • Best: For pigment intensity
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Castor oil and sunflower seed oil
  • Benefits: Conditioning, softening and thickening
  • Why we love it
    • Intense black pigment
    • Feels softening
    • Easy to remove

We were instantly wowed by the intense black pigment added to our lashes by this vegan-friendly mascara. The tapered brush fans eyelashes out smoothly, achieving both thickness and length, without our tester needing to add many coats.

As the formula is a serum for conditioning lashes and includes ingredients like castor oil and sunflower seed oil, it felt softening too. We saw fuller-looking eyelashes without product heaviness, and our tester didn’t find it difficult to remove either.

Back to top

Merit clean lash lengthening mascara, perfect black

best mascara
  • Best: For a natural look
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Olive oil esters, omega fatty acids and vitamin B5
  • Benefits: Weightless, gentle lash lift
  • Why we love it
    • Gentle on irritated eyes
    • Slimline brush makes for easy application

This tubing mascara contains conditioning ingredients, including vitamin B5, omega fatty acids and olive oil esters. Our tester has been wearing the Merit mascara for several months, since the brand’s UK launch, and finds it to be gentle on her easily irritated eyes, while providing a natural lash look with subtle length and volume. Our tester also rates this mascara’s slimline brush for application ease and full lash coverage. The black and gold packaging looks particularly luxe too.

Back to top

Tarte lights, camera, lashes four-in-one mascara

tarte mascara.jpg
  • Best: For top and bottom lashes
  • Colour: Black
  • Key ingredients: Olive esters and rice bran
  • Benefits: Thickening, lengthening and volumising
  • Why we love it
    • Vegan-friendly mascara
    • Formula conditions lashes

Tarte is a cult-classic make-up brand that is now available to buy in the UK, thanks to Sephora’s launch earlier in the year. Our tester has been using this vegan-friendly mascara for several years, and never experiences any eye irritation. Its medium-sized brush effectively grips and coats lashes, creating length and volume. Olive oil esters are included to condition lashes, while rice bran contains moisturising vitamin E. Our tester found it held in place well throughout the day, without any smudges or flakiness appearing. They’re a big fan of the purple glittery case too.

Back to top

The verdict: Mascara for sensitive eyes

Our overall favourite is It Cosmetics’ hello lashes+ for significantly lengthened lashes, smooth application and no stinging. Meanwhile, Pacifica’s vegan collagen fluffy lash mascara is a maximum impact mascara that feels comfy to wear. Finally, if you’re looking for volumised and thickened lashes that stay soft to the touch, we’d recommend TARTE’s lights, camera, lashes 4-in-1 mascara.

Looking for lash drama? Here are the best eyelash curlers to buy

Voucher Codes

TUI Discount Code
TUI Discount Code
£250 off a 7 night stay with the deal of the week - TUI discount code
ASOS Discount Code
ASOS Discount Code
10% off first orders £20+ using this ASOS promo code
Travelodge Discount Code
Travelodge Discount Code
Save 5% on bookings - Travelodge voucher code
The Body Shop Discount Code
The Body Shop Discount Code
Save 20% on orders with The Body Shop discount code
The Perfume Shop Discount Code
The Perfume Shop Discount Code
Save 15% on everything with birthday orders at The Perfume Shop - Member exclusive
Cult Beauty Discount Code
Cult Beauty Discount Code
Get 15% off + Extra 5% on select products with this Cult Beauty voucher code

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in