Support truly
independent journalism
Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.
Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.
Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.
![Louise Thomas](https://s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/static.independent.co.uk/static-assets/support-us/louise-thomas.png)
Louise Thomas
Editor
Beverley Knight's 2002 album Who I Am established her as Britain's foremost soul diva, with a taste and sensitivity way beyond most of her American R&B peers. Her secret weapon was her sincerity: her vocal lines never sounded like showy exercises, but seemed to derive naturally from the spirit of the songs - she had the instinctive ability to pick the right note and stick with it, without running pointlessly up and down the scale. Which makes the incursions of fluttering melisma creeping into some tracks of this follow-up all the more disappointing, especially since, as the gospel-flavoured "First Time" demonstrates, she's capable of the kind of true soul power wielded by the likes of Mavis Staples. The loss of a close friend to Aids brings an emotional charge to some songs, notably "No One Ever Loves in Vain". But it's another loss, that of the American production team of James Poyser and Che Guevara, who brought such lean, limber style to Who I Am, that affects the sound of Affi
Beverley Knight's 2002 album Who I Am established her as Britain's foremost soul diva, with a taste and sensitivity way beyond most of her American R&B peers. Her secret weapon was her sincerity: her vocal lines never sounded like showy exercises, but seemed to derive naturally from the spirit of the songs - she had the instinctive ability to pick the right note and stick with it, without running pointlessly up and down the scale. Which makes the incursions of fluttering melisma creeping into some tracks of this follow-up all the more disappointing, especially since, as the gospel-flavoured "First Time" demonstrates, she's capable of the kind of true soul power wielded by the likes of Mavis Staples. The loss of a close friend to Aids brings an emotional charge to some songs, notably "No One Ever Loves in Vain". But it's another loss, that of the American production team of James Poyser and Che Guevara, who brought such lean, limber style to Who I Am, that affects the sound of Affirmation more directly: on a track such as "Come as You Are", there's a clear disparity between the mildness of the subject matter ("This is a brand new dress/ No need to make a mess") and the bluster of the arrangement. For all that, she remains head and shoulders above her contemporaries, a real talent rather than an R&B mannequin.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments