The Champions League's three-tiered competition has led to a predictable three-tiered group stage draw
Tottenham and Chelsea face genuinely intriguing early ties but for Manchester United, City and Liverpool the Champions League will not truly begin until January
Your support helps us to tell the story
From reproductive rights to climate change to Big Tech, The Independent is on the ground when the story is developing. Whether it's investigating the financials of Elon Musk's pro-Trump PAC or producing our latest documentary, 'The A Word', which shines a light on the American women fighting for reproductive rights, we know how important it is to parse out the facts from the messaging.
At such a critical moment in US history, we need reporters on the ground. Your donation allows us to keep sending journalists to speak to both sides of the story.
The Independent is trusted by Americans across the entire political spectrum. And unlike many other quality news outlets, we choose not to lock Americans out of our reporting and analysis with paywalls. We believe quality journalism should be available to everyone, paid for by those who can afford it.
Your support makes all the difference.The feeling in the modern game is that the Champions League has become a troublesomely three-tiered competition, and so it was fitting that its 2017-18 grand opening round has been something of a three-tiered draw: for the English clubs, and the campaign in general.
As regards the Premier League sides, Manchester United and Liverpool have been given hugely forgiving groups; Chelsea and Manchester City have drawn relatively awkward groups in that they’re a bit tighter but still navigable; while Mauricio Pochettino’s bad luck in the European Cup seems to continue as Spurs were handed the unquestionable group of death with the defending champions. Celtic, meanwhile, should really just enjoy the experience.
Along the same lines - and as has become a little bit of an issue for the expanded Champions League in the last few years - the majority of the groups feel a little too easy to pick two qualifiers from.
It doesn’t always pan out like that, and there are of course always a few twists, but it would require some uncharacteristically severe twists for United-Benfica, Bayern-PSG and Barcelona-Juventus not to go through. It is harder to predict who will emerge from Chelsea-Atletico-Roma, Liverpool-Sevilla-Spartak and City-Napoli-Donetsk-Feyenoord but only because of questions about one of the places rather than properly tense groups of the type we saw in the mid to late 90s. The only two that have the capacity for those kind of high-octane high-pressure early European games involve Monaco-Porto-Besiktas-RB Leipzig and of course that Spurs group.
Most eyes will be on Group H most weeks. Real Madrid and Dortmund certainly aren’t the ideal opposition for Spurs to upend this supposed Wembley jinx, especially since it was in the Champions League group stages last season when the idea of that jinx effectively became concrete. There is also a theory around Spurs that their style is still a little bit too intense for the more patient approaches of Europe, explaining why they were so caught out last season.
Given they’re up against the champions and the strongest squad on the continent in Real, but an exciting Dortmund under new management as well as a very beatable Apoel, the difference of the challenges will tell a lot as to whether those previous struggles were down to style or mere lack of experience. How Antonio Conte attempts to figure out Diego Simeone’s Atletico Madrid will be just as engaging - as well as perhaps the most eye-catching tie of the entire round. The presence of a Monchi-guided Roma will also ensure there is more intensity to such group games than usual. There is similarly the added edge of Conte’s relatively underwhelming record from his two seasons in the Champions League to date, something he is all too conscious of.
The Premier League in general has had an underwhelming record in the last few years, but - as is another general problem with the group stage - that is more a discussion for the knock-out stages after Christmas, especially when United and Liverpool have such promising paths there.
Jose Mourinho and his club couldn’t have wished for a better draw in their respective returns to the competition, having avoided a heavyweight, just as Liverpool and City did.
Even if Jurgen Klopp and Pep Guardiola have more awkward challenges - particularly as regards Liverpool’s 2016 Europa League final rematch with Sevilla and City’s tantalising trip to Napoli - it would still take for something to go badly wrong for any of the three to go out so early.
The opposite is true for Celtic. It would really take something miraculous for them to oust Bayern or a Neymar-powered PSG, and that’s leaving aside the fact that Anderlecht are a difficult challenge in their own right for a Europa League place.
One positive of this season’s draw is that the seeding and general pool of teams have ensured we don’t seen a repeat of the same old ties we’d all got used to. Bayern-PSG feels genuinely refreshing, while Barca-Juventus haven’t quite played enough to bring any ennui from the fact this is the second time they’ve faced off in three years. If anything, that they have both won one of those ties - Barca’s victory bringing the 2015 title itself - will only add to it.
There are a few other touches of history that add to the fascination, like Mourinho returning to his first job in management as Benfica and United replay the 1968 final, while Monaco and Porto replay 2004 in what is arguably the least glamorous group but the most competitive.
How RB Leipzig adjust to the competition as a whole will decide that, but it says much about the group stage that none of this in general feels that decisive.
Beyond the trend of around one shock per season, it all feels like something of a pre-season stage rather than a first round proper for the big teams, the time when they find their feet and feel each other out rather than have to go toe to toe. It is why it is barely worth even discussing title credentials at this point, given that most of the super-clubs and those closest to them are guaranteed to be in the next draw in December.
It is a problem of a three-tiered competition, and has produced this three-tiered draw.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Comments