Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

What Brussels insiders really think about crunch Brexit talks

As summit begins, diplomats tell Jon Stone the time has come for Boris Johnson to eat his vegetables

Wednesday 14 October 2020 19:12 BST
Comments
Boris Johnson works the room at a previous EU summit
Boris Johnson works the room at a previous EU summit (Getty Images)

Brussels is putting aside its chats about budgets, Covid and climate change, to make way for an old favourite: for the first time since most of us had heard of "contact tracing", Brexit is back on the menu at an EU leaders' meeting.

Some summits are headline-grabbers because of what's said by leaders in public. This one will be important because of what's going on behind the scenes.

For once, EU diplomats expect "quite a lengthy discussion" on Brexit between heads of government, but by contrast, they are only anticipating a "succinct" public statement at the end that doesn't, at first glance, add much.

Indeed, a draft version of the communiqué prepared by officials has already leaked, and it's full of Brussels greatest hits: "intensifying" talks, progress not being "sufficient". It might as well be 2018.

Why the mismatch? For starters, this will be the first real discussion EU leaders have had on Brexit since the pandemic started, and they need to get up to speed.

But crucially, it will also be the first space for the EU to decide how much it really wants a deal and what – if any – compromises it would be willing to make. That will have to be hashed out.

There is no question of changing the official mandate given to chief negotiator Michel Barnier - on that, all member states are agreed. But there may be differences in emphasis and strategy to be worked out.

"It's a bit like one of your children not wanting to eat her or his veggies," one says.

"What can you do? It's wise to eat them because you have to grow up to be healthy and fit. Do you force it through her mouth? That's one option.

"The other way is to try and find another way around the issue and mix it with bananas or something. In the end it's the same, he or she will eat her veggies."

British officials detect room for compromise to emerge, and on some issues, like the so-called level playing field on regulations, there are chinks of light.

That issue has effectively boiled down to Britain wanting more freedom to set its own state aid rules, and has long looked intractable. But a recent UK decision to quietly give a little detail about what its domestic state aid regulator would look like has piqued the interest on the EU side and oiled the wheels a bit.

Meanwhile the UK believes the EU has moved away from a demand to get the European Court of Justice involved in the issue, relaxing a red line. Officials on both sides are starting to sound a bit upbeat about this one, even if it's hard to see the "landing zone" quite yet.

But on other topics like fishing, which is hugely politically charged whether you're looking at it from Dover or Dunkirk, there seems to have been essentially no serious movement – despite early noises by Michel Barnier about compromise.

On this issue, whatever is agreed, someone loses - and in an obvious and immediate way: you can either catch a fish or you can't. A deal here looks as far off as it ever has.

In some respects, the UK's recent antics have hindered rather than helped matters. The Internal Market Bill, which ministers admit breaks international law and overrides part of last year's hard-won deal on Northern Ireland, has genuinely ruffled feathers here.

"That has shown my government if we come to a possible solution, it has to come together with a very, very, very robust dispute settlement and governance system otherwise it will not fly," one diplomat, from a usually UK-sympathetic state says.

Don't expect this meeting to drop any big bombshells by itself. But keep an eye out for how Boris Johnson reacts to it later on Friday: what's discussed in the futuristic-looking Europa building away 

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in